Ecological Archives E080-008-S1

Larry V. Hedges, Jessica Gurevitch, and Peter S. Curtis. 1999. The meta-analysis of response ratio experiments in experimental ecology. Ecology 80: 1150-1156.



Supplement 1

Variables are described in the metadata
References correspond to paper numbers (column 2)
Additional comments contain additional information on each study, and are ordered by paper (reference) number

OBSNO PAP_NO PARAM  P_UNIT  GENUS SPECIES DIV1 DIV2 AMBC ELEV CO2_UNIT TIME POT METHOD STOCK XTRT LEVEL SOURCE X_AMB SE_AMB SD_AMB N_AMB X_ELEV SE_ELEV SD_ELEV N_ELEV

21

44

TOTWT mg ALNUS RUBRA WOODY N2FIX

350

650

ul/l

47

0.5

GC SEED FERT HI 20mgN/l T1

3945

499

1115.79

5

6816.9

1021.9

1769.98

3

22

44

TOTWT mg ALNUS RUBRA WOODY N2FIX

350

650

ul/l

47

0.5

GC SEED FERT CONTROL . T1

2251.2

146.5

327.583

5

2596.1

298.5

667.466

5

27

121

TOTWT g ACER RUBRUM WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ppm

59

2.6

GH SEED NONE . . T4

1.93

0.2469

0.552

5

2.99

0.3828

0.856

5

32

121

TOTWT g QUERCUS PRINUS WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ppm

70

2.6

GH SEED NONE . . T4

6.62

0.7294

1.631

5

5.91

0.779

1.742

5

35

121

TOTWT g MALUS DOMESTICA WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ppm

64

2.6

GH SEED NONE . . T4

4.1

0.6285

1.257

4

4.61

0.7035

1.407

4

38

121

TOTWT g ACER SACCHARINUM WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ppm

50

2.6

GH SEED NONE . . F2

6.42

1.17

2.026

3

10.78

0.52

1.163

5

44

159

TOTWT g CASTANEA SATIVA WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ppm

730

GRND GC SAP NONE . . T1

127.3

27.4

47.4582

3

153.5

15.7

27.1932

3

63

183

TOTWT g CITRUS SINENSIS WOODY ANGIO

395

795

ppm

365

9

GH SAP NONE . . T1

1140.6

47.9

82.965

3

1439

82

142.028

3

86

209

TOTWT g CASTANEA SATIVA WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ppm

365

24

GH SEED FERT HI .82,.78,.4NPg/mo F1

144.1

5.7467

25.7

20

183.6

8.7341

39.06

20

87

209

TOTWT g CASTANEA SATIVA WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ppm

365

24

GH SEED FERT CONTROL . F1

59.94

3.57

14.28

16

71.72

3.575

14.3

16

95

210

TOTWT g CASTANEA SATIVA WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ppm

120

12

GH SAP NONE . . T2

28.2

2.4813

11.9

23

45.8

3.533

15.8

20

96

210

TOTWT g CASTANEA SATIVA WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ppm

120

12

GH SAP NONE . . T3

60.5

2.8577

14

24

72.5

3.0619

15

24

120

290

TOTWT g PINUS RADIATA WOODY GYMNO

340

640

ul/l

120

4

GC SAP NONE . . T1

46.4

4.6315

13.1

8

59.1

4.5608

12.9

8

125

290

TOTWT g NOTHOFAGUS FUSCA WOODY ANGIO

340

640

ul/l

120

4

GC SAP NONE . . T1

4.2

0.3536

1

8

4.9

0.6718

1.9

8

130

290

TOTWT g PSEUDOTSUGA MENZIESII WOODY GYMNO

340

640

ul/l

120

4

GC SAP NONE . . T1

18.5

2.8638

8.1

8

19

1.9092

5.4

8

163

468

TOTWT g CASTANEA SATIVA WOODY ANGIO

350

700

umol/mol

1095

24

OTC SAP NONE . . T2

136

15.6525

35

5

146

4.4721

10

5

170

470

TOTWT g CASTANEA SATIVA WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ppm

180

24

OTC SAP NONE . . T4

90.4

10.3923

36

12

129

17.0318

59

12

182

503

TOTWT g PINUS ECHINATA WOODY GYMNO

368

695

ul/l

287

0.95

GC SEED NONE . . T1

6.81

0.7

1.57

5

6.91

1.44

3.22

5

208

505

TOTWT g QUERCUS ALBA WOODY ANGIO

389

793

cm3/m3

168

2.6

GH SEED FERT HI 5,1.5,1.9mgNPK/wk T2

14.62

1.026

2.294

5

17.89

4.555

10.185

5

209

505

TOTWT g QUERCUS ALBA WOODY ANGIO

389

793

cm3/m3

168

2.6

GH SEED FERT CONTROL . T2

11.18

2.571

5.749

5

14.68

2.242

5.013

5

230

506

TOTWT g LIRIODENDRON TULIPIFERA WOODY ANGIO

371

787

ppm

168

3.5

GC SEED FERT HI 20.,4-5,16.5NPK+mg/wk T3

54.03

0.7245

1.62

5

63.97

3.4257

7.66

5

231

506

TOTWT g LIRIODENDRON TULIPIFERA WOODY ANGIO

371

787

ppm

168

3.5

GC SEED FERT CONTROL . T3

4.93

0.6037

1.35

5

6.01

0.4562

1.02

5

236

510

TOTWT g QUERCUS ALBA WOODY ANGIO

360

700

ul/l

210

0.95

GC SEED NONE . . T2

8.2

1.37

3.3558

6

14.15

3.53

8.6467

6

242

510

TOTWT g PINUS ECHINATA WOODY GYMNO

360

700

ul/l

168

0.95

GC SEED NONE . . T1

1.33

0.06

0.1897

10

2.2

0.13

0.4111

10

254

550

TOTWT g BETULA PENDULA WOODY ANGIO

350

700

umol/mol

40

HYDRO GC SEED NONE . . F1A

14.94

0.18

0.8443

22

23.11

0.18

0.8443

22

256

553

TOTWT g PICEA ABIES WOODY GYMNO

350

750

cm3/m3

180

50

GC SAP OZONE HI 0.08cm3/m3 T1

235.5

6.1237

15

6

262.1

6.6953

16.4

6

257

553

TOTWT g PICEA ABIES WOODY GYMNO

350

750

cm3/m3

180

50

GC SAP OZONE LOW 0.02cm3/m3 T1

236.4

3.0619

7.5

6

273.3

5.7155

14

6

267

582

TOTWT g PIPER AURITUM WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ppm

111

0.67

GH SEED NONE . . F1a

8.81

1.03

2.06

4

10.14

1.26

2.52

4

277

582

TOTWT g SENNA MULTIJUGA WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ppm

111

0.67

GH SEED NONE . . F1a

13.22

0.97

1.94

4

15.72

1.38

2.76

4

287

582

TOTWT g MYRIOCARPA LONGIPES WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ppm

111

0.67

GH SEED NONE . . F1a

9.8

1.03

2.06

4

9.01

1.29

2.58

4

296

582

TOTWT g CECROPIA OBTUSIFOLIA WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ppm

111

0.67

GH SEED NONE . . F1a

18.6

1.17

2.34

4

21.33

1.53

3.06

4

306

582

TOTWT g TRICHOSPERMUM MEXICANUM WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ppm

111

0.67

GH SEED NONE . . F1a

12.18

1.23

2.46

4

14.68

1.41

2.82

4

313

596

TOTWT g BETULA LENTA WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

90

0.66

GH SEED NONE . . F1A

5.3

2.095

6.625

10

8.36

1.238

3.915

10

320

596

TOTWT g BETULA PAPYRIFERA WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

90

0.66

GH SEED NONE . . F1A

3.6

0.957

3.026

10

7.91

0.572

1.809

10

327

596

TOTWT g BETULA POPULIFOLIA WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

90

0.66

GH SEED NONE . . F1A

4.98

1.245

3.937

10

12.45

2.196

6.944

10

334

596

TOTWT g BETULA ALLEGHANIENSIS WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

90

0.66

GH SEED NONE . . F1A

4.01

0.666

2.106

10

7.84

1.051

3.324

10

343

666

TOTWT mg PINUS BANKSIANA WOODY GYMNO

350

750

umol/mol

270

0.04

GH SEED UVB HI 0.25-0.9W/m2 F1

73.82

26.34

83.294

10

93.16

22.58

71.404

10

344

666

TOTWT mg PINUS BANKSIANA WOODY GYMNO

350

750

umol/mol

270

0.04

GH SEED UVB LOW 0.005-0.3W/m2 F1

411.17

80.86

255.702

10

590.46

129.77

410.369

10

392

2003

TOTWT g BETULA PUBESCENS WOODY ANGIO

350

700

umol/mol

34

0.2

GC SEED TEMP HI 20degC T2

3.83

0.1

0.1414

2

4.77

0.14

0.198

2

393

2003

TOTWT g BETULA PUBESCENS WOODY ANGIO

350

700

umol/mol

34

0.2

GC SEED TEMP LOW 15degC T2

3.4

0.04

0.0566

2

3.74

0.03

0.0424

2

394

2003

TOTWT g BETULA PUBESCENS WOODY ANGIO

350

560

umol/mol

35

0.3

GC SEED OZONE HI 62nmol/mol T1

2.4

0.01

0.014

2

3.15

0.21

0.297

2

395

2003

TOTWT g BETULA PUBESCENS WOODY ANGIO

350

560

umol/mol

35

0.3

GC SEED OZONE LOW 7nmol/mol T1

3.17

0.3

0.424

2

3.78

0.3

0.424

2

410

2026

TOTWT g PINUS PONDEROSA WOODY GYMNO

350

650

ubar

60

1.8

GC SEED TEMP HI 30/15degC T3A

1.7

0.08

0.32

16

2.15

0.09

0.36

16

411

2026

TOTWT g PINUS PONDEROSA WOODY GYMNO

350

650

ubar

60

1.8

GC SEED TEMP LOW 25/10degC T3A

1.66

0.07

0.28

16

1.76

0.07

0.28

16

441

2037

TOTWT g ACER RUBRUM WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

1095

2.8

GH SEED FERT LOW 0.18g/slow F1

32.99

3.801

5.375

2

47.38

3.546

5.015

2

442

2037

TOTWT g ACER RUBRUM WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

1095

2.8

GH SEED LIGHT LOW 37%full F1

221

23.011

32.542

2

258.53

35.578

50.315

2

443

2037

TOTWT g ACER RUBRUM WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

1095

2.8

GH SEED FERT+L . 75%,1.8g F1

396.31

29.484

41.697

2

482.04

10.466

14.801

2

444

2037

TOTWT g QUERCUS RUBRA WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

1095

2.8

GH SEED FERT LOW 0.18g/slow F1

44.8

5.571

7.879

2

30.59

1.522

2.152

2

445

2037

TOTWT g QUERCUS RUBRA WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

1095

2.8

GH SEED LIGHT LOW 37%full F1

44.93

8.376

11.845

2

172.4

16.743

23.678

2

446

2037

TOTWT g QUERCUS RUBRA WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

1095

2.8

GH SEED FERT+L . 75%,1.8g F1

187.67

18.834

26.635

2

277.46

10.489

14.834

2

447

2037

TOTWT g ACER PENSYLVANICUM WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

1095

2.8

GH SEED FERT LOW 0.18g/slow F1

18.8

3.301

4.668

2

23.08

3.036

4.294

2

448

2037

TOTWT g ACER PENSYLVANICUM WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

1095

2.8

GH SEED LIGHT LOW 37%full F1

109.07

20.912

29.574

2

196.8

18.819

26.614

2

449

2037

TOTWT g ACER PENSYLVANICUM WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

1095

2.8

GH SEED FERT+L . 75%,1.8g F1

168.88

14.661

20.734

2

254.39

23.069

32.624

2

450

2037

TOTWT g BETULA POPULIFOLIA WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

1095

2.8

GH SEED FERT LOW 0.18g/slow F1

29.36

2.788

3.943

2

31.1

0.759

1.073

2

451

2037

TOTWT g BETULA POPULIFOLIA WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

1095

2.8

GH SEED LIGHT LOW 37%full F1

161.05

6.276

8.876

2

186

12.536

17.729

2

452

2037

TOTWT g BETULA POPULIFOLIA WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

1095

2.8

GH SEED FERT+L . 75%,1.8g F1

232.69

12.655

17.897

2

232.37

6.27

8.867

2

453

2037

TOTWT g FRAXINUS AMERICANA WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

1095

2.8

GH SEED FERT LOW 0.18g/slow F1

23.2

0.762

1.078

2

25.19

1.521

2.151

2

454

2037

TOTWT g FRAXINUS AMERICANA WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

1095

2.8

GH SEED LIGHT LOW 37%full F1

114.68

18.827

26.625

2

120.8

14.689

20.773

2

455

2037

TOTWT g FRAXINUS AMERICANA WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

1095

2.8

GH SEED FERT+L . 75%,1.8g F1

168.74

18.972

26.83

2

262.77

12.609

17.832

2

456

2037

TOTWT g BETULA ALLEGHANIENSIS WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

1095

2.8

GH SEED FERT LOW 0.18g/slow F1

26.49

1.266

1.79

2

38.36

2.273

3.215

2

457

2037

TOTWT g BETULA ALLEGHANIENSIS WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

1095

2.8

GH SEED LIGHT LOW 37%full F1

161.74

10.505

14.856

2

178.33

8.367

11.833

2

458

2037

TOTWT g BETULA ALLEGHANIENSIS WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

1095

2.8

GH SEED FERT+L . 75%,1.8g F1

180.48

8.391

11.867

2

186.26

8.368

11.834

2

479

2039

TOTWT g POPULUSX EURAMERICANA WOODY ANGIO

34.5

69.3

Pa

148

GRND OTC SAP FERT HI 346ugN/g/d;110mgextP/kgs T2

76

3

6.708

5

113

2

4.472

5

480

2039

TOTWT g POPULUSX EURAMERICANA WOODY ANGIO

34.5

69.3

Pa

148

GRND OTC SAP FERT LOW 45ugN/g/d;64mgextP/kgsoi T2

60

4

8.944

5

75

4

8.944

5

523

2045

TOTWT g PICEA MARIANA WOODY GYMNO

340

700

ppm

155

0.164

GC SEED H2O WW . T3

3.862

0.206

1.4272

48

4.773

0.31

2.1477

48

524

2045

TOTWT g PICEA MARIANA WOODY GYMNO

340

700

ppm

155

0.164

GC SEED H2O DRT . T3

2.49

0.095

0.6582

48

3.272

0.133

0.9215

48

525

2045

TOTWT g PICEA MARIANA WOODY GYMNO

340

700

ppm

155

0.164

GC SEED FERT HI . T3

4.031

0.187

1.2956

48

5.249

0.24

1.6628

48

526

2045

TOTWT g PICEA MARIANA WOODY GYMNO

340

700

ppm

155

0.164

GC SEED FERT LOW . T3

2.35

0.084

0.582

48

2.798

0.086

0.5958

48

547

2048

TOTWT g PICEA GLAUCA WOODY GYMNO

350

700

umol/mol

112

0.2

GC SEED UVB HI 150uW/cm2 T3

0.243

0.0373

0.118

10

0.333

0.0465

0.147

10

548

2048

TOTWT g PICEA GLAUCA WOODY GYMNO

350

700

umol/mol

112

0.2

GC SEED UVB LOW 1.1uW/cm2 T3

0.443

0.0411

0.13

10

0.64

0.0487

0.154

10

561

2048

TOTWT g PICEA MARIANA WOODY GYMNO

350

700

umol/mol

112

0.2

GC SEED UVB HI 150uW/cm2 T3

0.328

0.0402

0.127

10

0.498

0.0515

0.163

10

562

2048

TOTWT g PICEA MARIANA WOODY GYMNO

350

700

umol/mol

112

0.2

GC SEED UVB LOW 1.1uW/cm2 T3

0.55

0.0354

0.112

10

0.824

0.074

0.234

10

575

2048

TOTWT g PINUS BANKSIANA WOODY GYMNO

350

700

umol/mol

112

0.2

GC SEED UVB HI 150uW/cm2 T3

0.599

0.0417

0.132

10

0.843

0.074

0.234

10

576

2048

TOTWT g PINUS BANKSIANA WOODY GYMNO

350

700

umol/mol

112

0.2

GC SEED UVB LOW 1.1uW/cm2 T3

0.842

0.0478

0.151

10

1.533

0.1249

0.395

10

614

2110

TOTWT g POPULUS EURAMERICANA WOODY ANGIO

34.5

69.3

Pa

158

GRND OTC SAP FERT HI 15.0-15.2gN/Kgsoil T1

381.6

28.8

64.3988

5

562.8

27.9

62.3863

5

615

2110

TOTWT g POPULUS EURAMERICANA WOODY ANGIO

34.5

69.3

Pa

158

GRND OTC SAP FERT LOW 4.6-4.5gN/kgsoil T1

298.2

43.1

96.3745

5

374.4

49

109.567

5

623

2117

TOTWT g PICEA ABIES WOODY GYMNO

350

700

umol/mol

47

0.2

GH SEED TEMP HI 20/20degC T1

0.971

0.018

0.0255

2

1.092

0.021

0.0297

2

624

2117

TOTWT g PICEA ABIES WOODY GYMNO

350

700

umol/mol

47

0.2

GH SEED TEMP LOW 15/15degC T1

0.975

0.009

0.0127

2

1.12

0.01

0.0141

2

636

2117

TOTWT g BETULA PENDULA WOODY ANGIO

350

700

umol/mol

35

0.2

GH SAP TEMP HI 20/20degC T1

5.95

0.14

0.198

2

6.91

0.22

0.3111

2

637

2117

TOTWT g BETULA PENDULA WOODY ANGIO

350

700

umol/mol

35

0.2

GH SAP TEMP LOW 15/15degC T1

5.78

0.07

0.099

2

6.94

0.3

0.4243

2

721

2217

TOTWT g MARANTHES CORYMBOSA WOODY ANGIO

350

700

umol/mol

210

10

OTC SEED NONE . . T4

10.578

0.5411

1.21

5

16.959

0.9776

2.186

5

725

2223

TOTWT g ACER RUBRUM WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

165

1.25

GH SEED FERT LOW 0.18g/slow F1

2.24

0.16

0.3919

6

2.4

0.23

0.5634

6

726

2223

TOTWT g ACER RUBRUM WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

165

1.25

GH SEED LIGHT LOW 37%full F1

10.96

0.79

1.9351

6

16.98

0.8

1.9596

6

727

2223

TOTWT g ACER RUBRUM WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

165

1.25

GH SEED FERT+L . full,1.8g F1

19.5

0.92

2.2535

6

28.18

1.32

3.2333

6

731

2223

TOTWT g QUERCUS RUBRA WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

165

1.25

GH SEED FERT LOW 0.18g/slow F1

2.04

0.15

0.3674

6

3.09

0.3

0.7348

6

732

2223

TOTWT g QUERCUS RUBRA WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

165

1.25

GH SEED LIGHT LOW 37%full F1

4.36

1.01

2.474

6

13.8

0.99

2.425

6

733

2223

TOTWT g QUERCUS RUBRA WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

165

1.25

GH SEED FERT+L . full,1.8g F1

14.79

1.43

3.5028

6

18.2

1.3

3.1843

6

737

2223

TOTWT g ACER PENSYLVANICUM WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

165

1.25

GH SEED FERT LOW 0.18g/slow F1

1.51

0.07

0.1715

6

1.9

0.05

0.1225

6

738

2223

TOTWT g ACER PENSYLVANICUM WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

165

1.25

GH SEED LIGHT LOW 37%full F1

5.89

0.57

1.3962

6

10.23

0.25

0.6124

6

739

2223

TOTWT g ACER PENSYLVANICUM WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

165

1.25

GH SEED FERT+L . full,1.8g F1

13.8

0.65

1.5922

6

16.59

1.19

2.9149

6

743

2223

TOTWT g BETULA POPULIFOLIA WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

165

1.25

GH SEED FERT LOW 0.18g/slow F1

2.24

0.16

0.3919

6

2.34

0.11

0.2694

6

744

2223

TOTWT g BETULA POPULIFOLIA WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

165

1.25

GH SEED LIGHT LOW 37%full F1

11.48

0.82

2.0086

6

16.22

1.16

2.8414

6

745

2223

TOTWT g BETULA POPULIFOLIA WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

165

1.25

GH SEED FERT+L . full,1.8g F1

19.95

0.94

2.3025

6

24.55

0.57

1.3962

6

749

2223

TOTWT g FRAXINUS AMERICANA WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

165

1.25

GH SEED FERT LOW 0.18g/slow F1

2.14

0.2

0.4899

6

1.51

0.07

0.1715

6

750

2223

TOTWT g FRAXINUS AMERICANA WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

165

1.25

GH SEED LIGHT LOW 37%full F1

5.49

0.54

1.3227

6

9.12

0.65

1.5922

6

751

2223

TOTWT g FRAXINUS AMERICANA WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

165

1.25

GH SEED FERT+L . full,1.8g F1

13.49

0.31

0.7593

6

18.62

0.88

2.1556

6

755

2223

TOTWT g BETULA ALLEGHANIENSIS WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

165

1.25

GH SEED FERT LOW 0.18g/slow F1

1.48

0.07

0.1715

6

1.9

0.09

0.2205

6

756

2223

TOTWT g BETULA ALLEGHANIENSIS WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

165

1.25

GH SEED LIGHT LOW 37%full F1

8.71

0.62

1.5187

6

14.45

0.68

1.6657

6

757

2223

TOTWT g BETULA ALLEGHANIENSIS WOODY ANGIO

350

700

ul/l

165

1.25

GH SEED FERT+L . full,1.8g F1

16.59

0.39

0.9553

6

16.98

0.22

0.5389

6

765

2224

TOTWT g QUERCUS RUBRA WOODY ANGIO

385

642

ul/l

60

6

GC SEED NONE . . F1

7.2

1.5

2.5981

3

16.9

1

1.7321

3

774

2224

TOTWT g ACER SACCHARUM WOODY ANGIO

385

642

ul/l

60

6

GC SEED NONE . . F1

4.6

1

1.7321

3

7.2

1

1.7321

3

783

2224

TOTWT g POPULUS TREMULOIDES WOODY ANGIO

385

642

ul/l

60

6

GC SEED NONE . . F1

69.7

2.1

3.6373

3

102.6

3.6

6.2354

3

[Back to E080-008]