Ecological Archives M085-005-A6
John R. Morrongiello and Ronald E. Thresher. 2015. A statistical framework to explore ontogenetic growth variation among individuals and populations: a marine fish example. Ecological Monographs 85:93–115. http://dx.doi.org/10.1890/13-2355.1
Appendix F. Across-area supplementary results: model selection tables.
Table F1. Results of random effect structure model selection for across zone analyses. Test descriptions as per Appendix D Table D1. Best model is highlighted in bold. | specifies a random slope for a given random intercept. Zone:Year and Zone:Cohort specify the nesting of Year and Cohort within Zone. AAC: Age-at-capture.
model |
df |
AICc |
∆AICc |
log likelihood |
(Age|FishID)+(1|Zone:Year)+(1|Zone)+(1|Zone:Cohort) |
12 |
-1578.9 |
68.09 |
801.46 |
(Age|FishID)+(1|Zone:Year)+(1|Zone)+(Age|Zone:Cohort) |
14 |
-1602.23 |
44.76 |
815.12 |
(Age|FishID)+(1|Zone:Year)+(Age|Zone)+(1|Zone:Cohort) |
14 |
-1593.93 |
53.06 |
810.97 |
(Age|FishID)+(Age|Zone:Year)+(1|Zone)+(1|Zone:Cohort) |
14 |
-1614.74 |
32.25 |
821.38 |
(Age|FishID)+(1|Zone:Year)+(AAC|Zone)+(1|Zone:Cohort) |
14 |
-1594.27 |
52.72 |
811.15 |
(Age|FishID)+(Age|Zone:Year)+(1|Zone)+(Age|Zone:Cohort) |
16 |
-1632.57 |
14.42 |
832.3 |
(Age|FishID)+(Age|Zone:Year)+(Age|Zone)+(1|Zone:Cohort) |
16 |
-1624.4 |
22.59 |
828.21 |
(Age|FishID)+(1|Zone:Year)+(Age|Zone)+(Age|Zone:Cohort) |
16 |
-1612.77 |
34.22 |
822.4 |
(Age|FishID)+(Age|Zone:Year)+(AAC|Zone)+(1|Zone:Cohort) |
16 |
-1628.38 |
18.61 |
830.2 |
(Age|FishID)+(1|Zone:Year)+(AAC|Zone)+(Age|Zone:Cohort) |
16 |
-1614.52 |
32.47 |
823.27 |
(Age|FishID)+(1|Zone:Year)+(Age+AAC|Zone)+(1|Zone:Cohort) |
17 |
-1608.84 |
38.15 |
821.43 |
(Age|FishID)+(Age|Zone:Year)+(Age|Zone)+(Age|Zone:Cohort) |
18 |
-1639.13 |
7.86 |
837.58 |
(Age|FishID)+(Age|Zone:Year)+(AAC|Zone)+(Age|Zone:Cohort) |
18 |
-1643.5 |
3.49 |
839.76 |
(Age|FishID)+(1|Zone:Year)+(Age+AAC|Zone)+(Age|Zone:Cohort) |
19 |
-1625.08 |
21.91 |
831.56 |
(Age|FishID)+(Age|Zone:Year)+(Age+AAC|Zone)+(1|Zone:Cohort) |
19 |
-1633.75 |
13.24 |
835.89 |
(Age|FishID)+(Age|Zone:Year)+(Age+AAC|Zone)+(Age|Zone:Cohort) |
21 |
-1646.99 |
0 |
844.51 |
Table F2. Results of extrinsic effect model selection for across zone analyses. Test descriptions as per Table D1. Best model is highlighted in bold. Intrinsic effects: Age*Sex + Age-at-capture.
model |
Df |
AICc |
∆AICc |
log likelihood |
intrinsic effects |
21 |
-1646.99 |
26.82 |
844.51 |
AvTemp |
22 |
-1657.76 |
16.05 |
1034.183 |
TempAnom |
22 |
-1661.02 |
12.79 |
1036.303 |
AvTemp+TempAnom |
23 |
-1671.63 |
2.18 |
1043.204 |
AvTemp+AvTemp^2 |
23 |
-1655.73 |
18.08 |
1032.863 |
TempAnom+TempAnom^2 |
23 |
-1659.03 |
14.78 |
1035.009 |
AvTemp*TempAnom |
24 |
-1673.81 |
0 |
1044.622 |
AvTemp+TempAnom+AvTemp^2 |
24 |
-1669.67 |
4.14 |
1041.929 |
AvTemp+TempAnom+TempAnom^2 |
24 |
-1669.64 |
4.17 |
1041.91 |
AvTemp*TempAnom+AvTemp^2 |
25 |
-1672.12 |
1.69 |
1043.523 |
AvTemp*TempAnom+TempAnom^2 |
25 |
-1672.38 |
1.43 |
1043.692 |
AvTemp+TempAnom+AvTemp^2+TempAnom^2 |
25 |
-1667.65 |
6.16 |
1040.616 |
AvTemp*TempAnom+AvTemp^2+TempAnom^2 |
26 |
-1670.66 |
3.15 |
1042.573 |