Ecological Archives C006-105-A4
Ekananda Paudel, Gbadamassi G. O. Dossa, Marleen D. de Blécourt, Philip Beckschäfer, Jianchu Xu, and Rhett D. Harrison. 2015. Quantifying the factors affecting leaf litter decomposition across a tropical forest disturbance gradient. Ecosphere 6:267. http://dx.doi.org/10.1890/es15-00112.1
Appendix D. Model summaries.
Table D1. Summary of linear mixed-effects model for percent mass loss (log transformed) from leaf litter bags installed across a tropical forest disturbance gradient. Independent variables included, installation season (SEASON), disturbance category (FOR_TYPE), litter type (LIT_TYPE), bag type (BAG_TYPE) and all two-way interactions. Installment season (SEASON) had 2 levels: Dry = dry season (baseline) and Wet = wet season. Forest type (FOR_TYPE) had 3 levels: CC = mature forest (baseline), OC = regenerating forest and OL = open land. Litter type had 2 levels: Dipterocarpus (baseline) and Parashorea. Bag type (BAG_TYPE) had 2 levels: C_Mesh = coarse mesh (baseline, fauna access) and F_Mesh = fine mesh (fauna exclusion). The number of days since installation (DAYS) was modeled as a second order polynomial for the fixed time effect, as this was a repeated measures design, and we included a DAYS:SEASON interaction. Random effects included a random intercept for PLOT/SUBPLOT, as the subject level term, and a random slope for installment season to account for the heteroscedasticity of variance.
Random effects:
Groups |
Name |
Variance |
Std. Dev. |
SUB_PLOT.PLOT |
SEASON.Wet |
0.02629 |
0.1621 |
SUB_PLOT.PLOT.1 |
(Intercept) |
0.01091 |
0.1044 |
PLOT |
SEASON.Wet |
0.02319 |
0.1523 |
PLOT.1 |
(Intercept) |
0.02151 |
0.1467 |
Residual |
|
0.05205 |
0.2281 |
Fixed effects:
|
Estimate |
Std. Error |
t value |
Intercept |
2.6489 |
0.051 |
51.94 |
SEASONWet |
0.98773 |
0.05621 |
17.57 |
FOR_TYPEOC |
-0.0543 |
0.06836 |
-0.79 |
FOR_TYPEOL |
-0.10801 |
0.08445 |
-1.28 |
LIT_TYPEParashorea |
0.47255 |
0.01771 |
26.69 |
BAG_TYPEF_Mesh |
-0.13562 |
0.01773 |
-7.65 |
poly(DAYS, 2)1 |
37.10402 |
0.3625 |
102.36 |
poly(DAYS, 2)2 |
2.94047 |
0.3475 |
8.46 |
SEASONWet:FOR_TYPEOC |
-0.02615 |
0.07449 |
-0.35 |
SEASONWet:FOR_TYPEOL |
-0.62543 |
0.09184 |
-6.81 |
SEASONWet:LIT_TYPEParashorea |
-0.02699 |
0.01639 |
-1.65 |
SEASONWet:BAG_TYPEF_Mesh |
-0.03749 |
0.01641 |
-2.28 |
SEASONWet:poly(DAYS, 2)1 |
-24.9217 |
0.4973 |
-50.11 |
SEASONWet:poly(DAYS, 2)2 |
-11.2644 |
0.4946 |
-22.77 |
FOR_TYPEOC:LIT_TYPEParashorea |
0.02194 |
0.01816 |
1.21 |
FOR_TYPEOL:LIT_TYPEParashorea |
-0.09181 |
0.02344 |
-3.92 |
FOR_TYPEOC:BAG_TYPEF_Mesh |
-0.07279 |
0.01816 |
-4.01 |
FOR_TYPEOL:BAG_TYPEF_Mesh |
-0.18194 |
0.02347 |
-7.75 |
LIT_TYPEParashorea:BAG_TYPEF_Mesh |
0.10298 |
0.01637 |
6.29 |
Table D2. Summary of linear mixed-effects model for percent mass loss (log transformed) from leaf litter bags installed in a shade-house mesocosm experiment, with three levels of simulated canopy cover and three litter-bed treatments. Independent variables included, installation season (SEASON), simulated canopy cover (SIM_CC), litter-bed disturbance category (FOR_TYPE), litter type (LIT_TYPE) and all two-way interactions. Installment season (SEASON) had 2 levels: Dry = dry season (baseline) and Wet = wet season. Simulated canopy cover had three levels: full-shade (baseline, two layers of shade-cloth), half-shade (HS, one layer of shade-cloth) and open-canopy (OP, no shade-cloth). Liter-bed forest type (FOR_TYPE) had 3 levels: CC = mature forest (baseline), OC = regenerating forest and OL = open land. Litter type had 2 levels: Dipterocarpus (baseline) and Parashorea. The number of days since installation (DAYS) was modeled as a second order polynomial for the fixed time effect, as this was a repeated measures design, and we included a DAYS:SEASON interaction. Random effects included a random intercept for ROW:COL/PLOT, as the subject level term, and a random slope for installment season to account for the heteroscedasticity of variance.
Random effects:
Groups |
Name |
Variance |
Std. Dev. |
ROW:COL:PLOT |
SEASON.Wet |
0.002686 |
0.051822 |
ROW:COL |
(Intercept) |
0.000053 |
0.007281 |
Residual |
0.07912 |
0.077450 |
0.278306 |
Fixed effects:
|
Estimate |
Std. Error |
t value |
(Intercept) |
1.869071 |
0.043936 |
42.54 |
SEASONWet |
1.36706 |
0.055837 |
24.48 |
poly(DAYS, 2)1 |
23.761881 |
0.393399 |
60.4 |
poly(DAYS, 2)2 |
-2.263696 |
0.376596 |
-6.01 |
SIM_CCHS |
-0.005886 |
0.046764 |
-0.13 |
SIM_CCOP |
0.25303 |
0.046764 |
5.41 |
LIT_TYPEParashorea |
0.575858 |
0.05356 |
10.75 |
FOR_TYPEOC |
0.016536 |
0.046384 |
0.36 |
FOR_TYPEOL |
-0.032373 |
0.046384 |
-0.7 |
SEASONWet:poly(DAYS, 2)1 |
-14.436745 |
0.556955 |
-25.92 |
SEASONWet:poly(DAYS, 2)2 |
-0.487704 |
0.559238 |
-0.87 |
SEASONWet:SIM_CCHS |
-0.448089 |
0.056277 |
-7.96 |
SEASONWet:SIM_CCOP |
-0.948146 |
0.056277 |
-16.85 |
SEASONWet:LIT_TYPEParashorea |
0.098336 |
0.043732 |
2.25 |
SEASONWet:FOR_TYPEOC |
-0.083887 |
0.056277 |
-1.49 |
SEASONWet:FOR_TYPEOL |
-0.056509 |
0.056277 |
-1 |
SIM_CCHS:LIT_TYPEParashorea |
-0.067359 |
0.05356 |
-1.26 |
SIM_CCOP:LIT_TYPEParashorea |
-0.207467 |
0.05356 |
-3.87 |
LIT_TYPEParashorea:FOR_TYPEOC |
0.02027 |
0.05356 |
0.38 |
LIT_TYPEParashorea:FOR_TYPEOL |
-0.008388 |
0.05356 |
-0.16 |
Table D3. Summary of linear mixed-effects model for percent mass loss (log transformed) from leaf litter bags installed across a tropical forest disturbance gradient. Independent variables included, installation season (SEASON), plant species composition (NMDS1 and NMDS2), litter type (LIT_TYPE), bag type (BAG_TYPE) and all two-way interactions. Installment season (SEASON) had 2 levels: Dry = dry season (baseline) and Wet = wet season. Plant species composition (trees, herbs, lianas) was represented by the first two axes of an NMDS ordination (see Fig. 5). Litter type had 2 levels: Dipterocarpus (baseline) and Parashorea. Bag type (BAG_TYPE) had 2 levels: C_Mesh = coarse mesh (baseline, fauna access) and F_Mesh = fine mesh (fauna exclusion). The number of days since installation (DAYS) was modeled as a second order polynomial for the fixed time effect, as this was a repeated measures design, and we included a DAYS:SEASON interaction. Random effects included a random intercept for PLOT/SUBPLOT, as the subject level term, and a random slope for installment season to account for the heteroscedasticity of variance. Note response data were the same as in Table A3 but the analysis replaced FOR_TYPE with plant species composition data.
Random effects:
Groups |
Name |
Variance |
Std. Dev. |
SUB_PLOT.PLOT |
SEASON.Wet |
0.02602 |
0.1613 |
SUB_PLOT.PLOT.1 |
(Intercept) |
0.01108 |
0.1052 |
PLOT |
SEASON.Wet |
0.02236 |
0.1495 |
PLOT.1 |
(Intercept) |
0.01549 |
0.1244 |
Residual |
|
0.05241 |
0.2289 |
Fixed effects:
|
Estimate |
Std. Error |
t value |
Intercept |
2.61389 |
0.02704 |
96.66 |
SEASONWet |
0.81562 |
0.03271 |
24.93 |
poly(DAYS, 2)1 |
36.93878 |
0.36358 |
101.60 |
poly(DAYS, 2)2 |
2.89596 |
0.3486 |
8.31 |
LIT_TYPEParashorea |
0.45145 |
0.01154 |
39.10 |
BAG_TYPEF_Mesh |
-0.22481 |
0.01165 |
-19.30 |
NMDS1 |
0.14647 |
0.06861 |
2.13 |
NMDS2 |
-0.29127 |
0.11214 |
-2.60 |
SEASONWet:NMDS1 |
0.5841 |
0.08353 |
6.99 |
SEASONWet:NMDS2 |
0.36838 |
0.13662 |
2.70 |
SEASONWet:poly(DAYS, 2)1 |
-24.7967 |
0.49879 |
-49.71 |
SEASONWet:poly(DAYS, 2)2 |
-11.2242 |
0.49607 |
-22.63 |
LIT_TYPEParashorea:BAG_TYPEF_Mesh |
0.1 |
0.01649 |
6.07 |
NMDS1:LIT_TYPEParashorea |
0.06576 |
0.02205 |
2.98 |
NMDS2:LIT_TYPEParashorea |
0.09477 |
0.03516 |
2.70 |
NMDS1:BAG_TYPEF_Mesh |
0.1741 |
0.02207 |
7.89 |
NMDS2:BAG_TYPEF_Mesh |
-0.0822 |
0.03519 |
-2.34 |
Table D4. Summary of linear mixed-effects model for percent mass loss (log transformed) from leaf litter bags installed across a tropical forest disturbance gradient. Independent variables included, installation season (SEASON), soil/topography (PCA1 and PCA2), litter type (LIT_TYPE), bag type (BAG_TYPE) and all two-way interactions. Installment season (SEASON) had 2 levels: Dry = dry season (baseline) and Wet = wet season. Soil (see Appendix C: Table A2) /topographic data was represented by the first two axes of a principal components ordination (see Fig. 7). Litter type had 2 levels: Dipterocarpus (baseline) and Parashorea. Bag type (BAG_TYPE) had 2 levels: C_Mesh = coarse mesh (baseline, fauna access) and F_Mesh = fine mesh (fauna exclusion). The number of days since installation (DAYS) was modeled as a second order polynomial for the fixed time effect, as this was a repeated measures design, and we included a DAYS:SEASON interaction. Random effects included a random intercept for PLOT/SUBPLOT, as the subject level term, and a random slope for installment season to account for the heteroscedasticity of variance. Note response data were the same as in Table A3 but the analysis replaced FOR_TYPE with soil/topographic data.
Random effects:
Groups |
Name |
Variance |
Std. Dev. |
SUB_PLOT.PLOT |
SEASON.Wet |
0.025072 |
0.15834 |
SUB_PLOT.PLOT.1 |
(Intercept) |
0.009304 |
0.09646 |
PLOT |
SEASON.Wet |
0.091065 |
0.30177 |
PLOT.1 |
(Intercept) |
0.031865 |
0.17851 |
Residual |
|
0.053635 |
0.23159 |
Fixed effects:
|
Estimate |
Std. Error |
t value |
Intercept |
2.61216 |
0.036137 |
72.29 |
SEASONWet |
0.813478 |
0.059324 |
13.71 |
poly(DAYS, 2)1 |
36.95171 |
0.368167 |
100.37 |
poly(DAYS, 2)2 |
2.882306 |
0.353112 |
8.16 |
LIT_TYPEParashorea |
0.452623 |
0.011652 |
38.85 |
BAG_TYPEF_Mesh |
-0.21841 |
0.011754 |
-18.58 |
PCA1 |
-0.01583 |
0.009679 |
-1.64 |
PCA2 |
0.036771 |
0.011865 |
3.1 |
SEASONWet:PCA1 |
-0.01078 |
0.014535 |
-0.74 |
SEASONWet:PCA2 |
0.008874 |
0.018142 |
0.49 |
SEASONWet:poly(DAYS, 2)1 |
-24.8 |
0.504946 |
-49.11 |
SEASONWet:poly(DAYS, 2)2 |
-11.2003 |
0.502153 |
-22.3 |
LIT_TYPEParashorea:BAG_TYPEF_Mesh |
0.099707 |
0.01668 |
5.98 |
PCA1:LIT_TYPEParashorea |
0.004785 |
0.004262 |
1.12 |
PCA2:LIT_TYPEParashorea |
0.003213 |
0.004735 |
0.68 |
PCA1:BAG_TYPEF_Mesh |
0.008834 |
0.004263 |
2.07 |
PCA2:BAG_TYPEF_Mesh |
-0.01578 |
0.004749 |
-3.32 |