Ecological Archives E096-266-A1
Stacey M. Trevathan-Tackett, Jeffrey Kelleway, Peter I. Macreadie, John Beardall, Peter Ralph, and Alecia Bellgrove. 2015. Comparison of marine macrophytes for their contributions to blue carbon sequestration. Ecology 96:3043–3057. http://dx.doi.org/10.1890/15-0149.1
Appendix A. Supplementary results: Average temperature intervals for each macrophyte order and raw thermogravimetric data for all samples.
Fig. A1. Relative per cent contribution of temperature intervals (TI) to total mass loss (180–800°C) of each order for (a) photosynthetic tissues and (b) attachment organs. Symbols represent mean ± 1 SE.
Table A1. Temperature averages (± 1SEM) individual species (n = 3). Raw and normalized data to total mass loss are shown. TI = temperature interval, Inorg = inorganics.
|
|||||||||
Kingdom |
Order |
Species |
Tissue |
Total Mass Loss (180–800°C) |
TI1 (180–300°C) |
TI2 (300–400°C) |
TI3 (400–600°C) |
TI Inorg (600–800°C) |
|
Protista |
Fucales |
Durvillaea potatorum |
Blade |
Raw |
57.72 (0.82) |
30.61 (0.81) |
10.78 (0.12) |
10.24 (0.11) |
6.10 (0.10) |
Normalized |
|
53.01 (0.71) |
18.68 (0.06) |
17.75 (0.39) |
10.57 (0.28) |
||||
Durvillaea potatorum |
Holdfast |
Raw |
54.49 (2.39) |
30.04 (1.79) |
9.55 (0.34) |
9.78 (0.38) |
5.11 (0.18) |
||
Normalized |
|
55.06 (1.22) |
17.57 (0.74) |
17.96 (0.14) |
9.40 (0.34) |
||||
Hormosira banksii |
Thallus |
Raw |
55.47 (2.66) |
29.21 (1.25) |
9.06 (0.93) |
9.56 (0.37) |
7.63 (0.24) |
||
Normalized |
|
52.69 (0.61) |
16.26 (0.88) |
17.26 (0.19) |
13.80 (0.48) |
||||
Phyllospora comosa |
Blade |
Raw |
56.04 (0.85) |
28.06 (0.57) |
13.43 (0.69) |
9.88 (0.38) |
4.67 (0.10) |
||
Normalized |
|
50.06 (0.43) |
23.95 (0.93) |
17.66 (0.93) |
8.33 (0.17) |
||||
Phyllospora comosa |
Holdfast |
Raw |
60.45 (0.73) |
29.82 (0.39) |
12.59 (0.23) |
8.45 (0.65) |
9.59 (0.34) |
||
Normalized |
|
49.34 (0.30) |
20.84 (0.57) |
13.96 (0.93) |
15.87 (0.62) |
||||
Laminariales |
Ecklonia radiata |
Blade |
Raw |
57.71 (4.46) |
31.50 (5.90) |
13.21 (1.52) |
8.40 (0.38) |
4.60 (0.10) |
|
Normalized |
|
53.66 (6.21) |
23.56 (4.44) |
14.69 (1.07) |
8.09 (0.79) |
||||
Ecklonia radiata |
Holdfast |
Raw |
57.31 (0.83) |
33.06 (1.25) |
10.69 (0.89) |
8.89 (0.48) |
4.66 (0.07) |
||
Normalized |
|
57.66 (1.41) |
18.70 (1.82) |
15.50 (0.64) |
8.14 (0.22) |
||||
Macrocystic pyrifera |
Blade |
Raw |
54.88 (2.59) |
26.43 (3.04) |
13.91 (0.77) |
8.86 (0.14) |
5.68 (0.08) |
||
Normalized |
|
47.87 (3.22) |
25.54 (2.33) |
16.20 (0.53) |
10.39 (0.37) |
||||
Macrocystic pyrifera |
Holdfast |
Raw |
54.26 (1.20) |
28.53 (1.15) |
11.86 (0.37) |
8.51 (0.25) |
5.37 (0.13) |
||
Normalized |
|
52.57 (0.75) |
21.85 (0.55) |
15.68 (0.33) |
9.89 (0.13) |
||||
Plocamiales |
Plocamium angustum |
Thallus |
Raw |
58.69 (1.06) |
19.36 (0.05) |
13.07 (0.16) |
11.59 (0.87) |
14.68 (0.27) |
|
Normalized |
|
33.02 (0.68) |
22.27 (0.25) |
19.70 (1.17) |
25.01 (0.41) |
||||
Planta |
Alismatales |
Amphibolis antarctica |
Leaves |
Raw |
63.78 (2.10) |
24.07 (0.57) |
26.58 (1.40) |
8.65 (0.07) |
4.49 (0.41) |
Normalized |
|
37.78 (0.85) |
41.62 (0.84) |
13.59 (0.54) |
7.01 (0.43) |
||||
Amphibolis antarctica |
Rhizome |
Raw |
64.35 (1.28) |
21.59 (0.73) |
29.17 (0.52) |
8.23 (0.53) |
5.37 (1.02) |
||
Normalized |
|
33.53 (0.56) |
45.33 (0.40) |
12.79 (0.83) |
8.35 (1.54) |
||||
Zostera muelleri |
Leaves |
Raw |
58.27 (1.05) |
16.55 (0.41) |
24.73 (0.26) |
11.75 (0.17) |
5.25 (0.32) |
||
Normalized |
|
28.39 (0.21) |
42.45 (0.58) |
20.17 (0.15) |
8.99 (0.40) |
||||
Zostera muelleri |
Rhizome |
Raw |
56.32 (2.43) |
19.63 (1.96) |
18.45 (1.06) |
7.38 (0.75) |
10.87 (1.18) |
||
Normalized |
|
34.68 (2.13) |
32.72 (0.70) |
13.05 (0.87) |
19.56 (3.03) |
||||
Zostera nigracaulis |
Leaves |
Raw |
56.38 (0.23) |
14.63 (0.63) |
25.39 (0.94) |
9.66 (0.17) |
6.70 (0.80) |
||
Normalized |
|
25.96 (1.18) |
45.02 (1.52) |
17.13 (0.31) |
11.89 (1.43) |
||||
Zostera nigracaulis |
Rhizome |
Raw |
54.50 (0.56) |
15.51 (0.66) |
21.12 (1.22) |
8.39 (0.16) |
9.48 (1.21) |
||
Normalized |
|
28.44 (0.99) |
38.72 (1.87) |
15.40 (0.40) |
17.44 (2.39) |
||||
Caryophyllales |
Tecticornia arbuscula |
Leaves |
Raw |
69.12 (0.45) |
31.09 (0.64) |
20.98 (0.57) |
13.14 (0.69) |
3.91 (0.40) |
|
Normalized |
|
44.99 (1.17) |
30.34 (0.70) |
19.00 (0.89) |
5.66 (0.59) |
||||
Tecticornia arbuscula |
Roots |
Raw |
70.83 (0.85) |
36.60 (1.08) |
17.33 (1.69) |
14.42 (1.53) |
2.47 (0.04) |
||
Normalized |
|
51.68 (1.37) |
24.42 (2.11) |
20.42 (2.40) |
3.49 (0.04) |
||||
Lamiales |
Avicennia marina |
Leaves |
Raw |
69.83 (1.24) |
27.03 (0.31) |
21.03 (0.27) |
18.12 (0.69) |
3.64 (0.22) |
|
Normalized |
|
38.72 (0.26) |
30.13 (0.47) |
25.93 (0.54) |
5.21 (0.29) |
||||
Poales |
Puccinellia sp. |
Leaves |
Raw |
74.32 (3.80) |
21.89 (0.31) |
37.30 (2.22) |
11.26 (0.98) |
3.88 (0.41) |
|
Normalized |
|
29.56 (1.15) |
50.15 (0.66) |
15.10 (0.59) |
5.19 (0.28) |
||||
Puccinellia sp. |
Roots |
Raw |
50.97 (4.84) |
18.41 (2.26) |
19.67 (2.65) |
9.16 (0.44) |
3.73 (0.15) |
||
Normalized |
|
35.94 (1.08) |
38.31 (2.29) |
18.24 (1.72) |
7.50 (1.01) |
||||
|
|||||||||
|
|||||||||
|
|||||||||
Total Mass Loss (180–800°C) |
TIA (180–410°C) |
TIB (410–600°C) |
TI Inorg (600–800°C) |
||||||
Protista |
Caulerpales |
Caulerpa cactoides |
Blade |
Raw |
36.62 (13.72) |
29.93 (11.88) |
4.60 (1.48) |
2.09 (0.37) |
|
Normalized |
|
80.03 (2.52) |
13.14 (0.80) |
6.82 (1.73) |
|||||
Caulerpa cactoides |
Stolon |
Raw |
32.14 (11.22) |
25.36 (9.71) |
4.36 (0.78) |
2.42 (0.74) |
|||
Normalized |
|
76.77 (3.10) |
15.50 (2.79) |
7.75 (0.34) |
|||||
Corallinales |
Corallina officinalis |
Thallus |
Raw |
50.65 (0.72) |
9.22 (1.67) |
4.16 (0.42) |
37.27 (1.63) |
||
Normalized |
|
18.15 (3.15) |
8.20 (0.74) |
73.66 (3.88) |