Sigrid D. P. Smith, Peter B. McIntyre, Benjamin S. Halpern, Roger M. Cooke, Adrienne L. Marino, Gregory L. Boyer, Andy Buchsbaum, G. A. Burton Jr., Linda M. Campbell, Jan J. H. Ciborowski, Patrick J. Doran,11 Dana M. Infante,12 Lucinda B. Johnson, Jennifer G. Read, Joan B. Rose, Edward S. Rutherford, Alan D. Steinman, and J. David Allan. 2015. Rating impacts in a multi-stressor world: a quantitative assessment of 50 stressors affecting the Great Lakes. Ecological Applications 25:717–728. http://dx.doi.org/10.1890/14-0366.1
Supplement
The relative potential impact of 50 stressors in 30 habitats in the Laurentian Great Lakes based on expert elicitation.
Ecological Archives A025-041-S1.
Authors
File list (downloads)
Description
Sigrid D. P. Smith
School of Natural Resources and Environment, University of Michigan
Ann Arbor, MI 48109 USA
E-mail: [email protected]
Peter B. McIntyre
Center for Limnology, University of Wisconsin-Madison
Madison, WI 53706 USA
Benjamin S. Halpern
1: Bren School of Environmental Science and Management, University of California
Santa Barbara, CA 93106 USA
2: Imperial College London, Silwood Park Campus, Buckhurst Road
Ascot SL57PY UK
3: National Center for Ecological Analysis and Synthesis, 735 State St. Suite 300
Santa Barbara, CA, 93101 USA
Roger M. Cooke
Resources for the Future
Washington, DC 20036 USA
Adrienne L. Marino
School of Natural Resources and Environment, University of Michigan
Ann Arbor, MI 48109 USA
Present address: University of Michigan Water Center, Graham Sustainability Institute, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI 48109 USA
Gregory L. Boyer
Great Lakes Research Consortium and College of Environmental Science and Forestry, State University of New York
Syracuse, NY 13210 USA
Andy Buchsbaum
Great Lakes Regional Center, National Wildlife Federation
Ann Arbor, MI 48104 USA
G. A. Burton Jr.
School of Natural Resources and Environment, University of Michigan
Ann Arbor, MI 48019 USA
Linda M. Campbell
School of Environmental Studies and Department of Biology, Queen's University, Kingston, Ontario, K7L 3N6 Canada
Present address: Environmental Science Program, St. Mary's University, Halifax, NS B3H-3C3 Canada
Jan J. H. Ciborowski
Department of Biological Sciences, University of Windsor
Windsor, ON N9B-3P4 Canada
Patrick J. Doran
The Nature Conservancy Great Lakes Project
Lansing, MI 48906 USA
Dana M. Infante
Department of Fisheries and Wildlife, Michigan State University
East Lansing, MI 48824 USA
Lucinda B. Johnson
Natural Resources Research Institute, University of Minnesota
Duluth, MN 55881 USA
Jennifer G. Read
School of Natural Resources and Environment, University of Michigan
Ann Arbor, MI 48109 USA
Present address: University of Michigan Water Center, Graham Sustainability Institute, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI 48109 USA
Joan B. Rose
Department of Fisheries and Wildlife, Michigan State University
East Lansing, MI 48824 USA
Edward S. Rutherford
NOAA, Great Lakes Environmental Research Lab
Ann Arbor, MI 48015 USA
Alan D. Steinman
Annis Water Resources Institute, Grand Valley State University
Muskegon, MI 49441 USA
J. David Allan
School of Natural Resources and Environment, University of Michigan
Ann Arbor, MI 48109 USA
File list
gleam_survey_ms_supp1_score_matrix.csv (MD5: fa3b7c9cbf4efb2dd00d27b78e65a138) Impact ratings (50 stressors x 30 habitats)
Description
This file contains the potential impact of each of 50 environmental stressors on ecosystem condition in the Laurentian Great Lakes. Data were derived from two parts of an online survey completed by scientific researchers, natural resource managers, and non-governmental organization representatives. In one part (Part III of the survey; Appendix A), respondents ranked 20 hypothetical scenarios to derive weights for 5 components of ecosystem impact (spatial extent, temporal frequency, ecological scope, magnitude of change, and recovery time). In the other part (Part IV; Appendix A), respondents rated the 5 components for each stressor in their chosen focal lake(s) and ecosystem zone(s). A weighted sum was used to derive these 0 (no impact) - 5 (highest impact)range relative ratings.
In the data file, columns are environmental stressors (2 capital letters for category, and 34 lower case letters for stressor name); rows are habitats (lakezone combinations). Abbreviations for lakes, zones, and stressors follow.
Lake-zone abbr |
Lake |
Zone |
ls_zwr |
Superior |
wetlands and rivermouths |
ls_zlh |
Superior |
littoral, hard substrate |
ls_zls |
Superior |
littoral, soft substrate |
ls_zsh |
Superior |
sublittoral, hard substrate |
ls_zss |
Superior |
sublittoral, soft substrate |
ls_zo |
Superior |
offshore |
lm_zwr |
Michigan |
wetlands and rivermouths |
lm_zlh |
Michigan |
littoral, hard substrate |
lm_zls |
Michigan |
littoral, soft substrate |
lm_zsh |
Michigan |
sublittoral, hard substrate |
lm_zss |
Michigan |
sublittoral, soft substrate |
lm_zo |
Michigan |
offshore |
lh_zwr |
Huron |
wetlands and rivermouths |
lh_zlh |
Huron |
littoral, hard substrate |
lh_zls |
Huron |
littoral, soft substrate |
lh_zsh |
Huron |
sublittoral, hard substrate |
lh_zss |
Huron |
sublittoral, soft substrate |
lh_zo |
Huron |
offshore |
le_zwr |
Erie |
wetlands and rivermouths |
le_zlh |
Erie |
littoral, hard substrate |
le_zls |
Erie |
littoral, soft substrate |
le_zsh |
Erie |
sublittoral, hard substrate |
le_zss |
Erie |
sublittoral, soft substrate |
le_zo |
Erie |
offshore |
lo_zwr |
Ontario |
wetlands and rivermouths |
lo_zlh |
Ontario |
littoral, hard substrate |
lo_zls |
Ontario |
littoral, soft substrate |
lo_zsh |
Ontario |
sublittoral, hard substrate |
lo_zss |
Ontario |
sublittoral, soft substrate |
lo_zo |
Ontario |
offshore |
Stressor abbr |
Stressor category |
Stressor name |
AQchan |
aquatic habitat alterations |
channel dredging |
AQhyp |
aquatic habitat alterations |
hypoxia |
AQport |
aquatic habitat alterations |
industrial ports and harbors |
AQlite |
aquatic habitat alterations |
light pollution |
AQboat |
aquatic habitat alterations |
marinas and recreational boating |
AQship |
aquatic habitat alterations |
shipping lanes |
AQext |
aquatic habitat alterations |
shoreline extensions |
AQhard |
aquatic habitat alterations |
shoreline hardening |
AQsubm |
aquatic habitat alterations |
submerged cables and pipelines |
AQdflo |
aquatic habitat alterations |
tributary dams (altered flow, sediment retention) |
AQdfis |
aquatic habitat alterations |
tributary dams (barriers to fish passage) |
CCwatl |
climate change |
changing water levels |
CCice |
climate change |
decreasing ice cover |
CCtemp |
climate change |
warming water temperatures |
CDdev |
coastal development |
coastal development (residential and commercial) |
CDmine |
coastal development |
coastal mining |
CDpowr |
coastal development |
coastal power plants |
CDrec |
coastal development |
coastal recreational use |
CDroad |
coastal development |
coastal road density |
FIcult |
fisheries management |
aquaculture |
FIcomm |
fisheries management |
commercial fishing |
FIdip |
fisheries management |
Diporeia decline |
FInats |
fisheries management |
native fish stocking |
FInns |
fisheries management |
non-native fish stocking |
FIrchr |
fisheries management |
recreational fishing - charter |
FIrnch |
fisheries management |
recreational fishing - non-charter |
INblst |
invasive and nuisance species |
ballast water invasion risk |
INfdis |
invasive and nuisance species |
emerging fish diseases |
INhab |
invasive and nuisance species |
harmful algal blooms |
INsubp |
invasive and nuisance species |
invasive underwater plants |
INplkt |
invasive and nuisance species |
invasive planktonic species |
INfish |
invasive and nuisance species |
invasive fish |
INlamp |
invasive and nuisance species |
invasive sea lamprey |
INwetp |
invasive and nuisance species |
invasive wetland plants |
INmus |
invasive and nuisance species |
invasive zebra and quagga mussels |
INbalg |
invasive and nuisance species |
nuisance benthic algal blooms |
NPcso |
nonpoint source pollution |
combined sewer overflows |
NPnlod |
nonpoint source pollution |
nitrogen loading |
NPphar |
nonpoint source pollution |
pharmaceutical loading |
NPplod |
nonpoint source pollution |
phosphorus loading |
NPsed |
nonpoint source pollution |
sediment loading |
TXaoc |
toxic chemical pollution |
areas of concern |
TXemer |
toxic chemical pollution |
emerging toxic chemicals |
TXmetb |
toxic chemical pollution |
toxic metals - biomagnifying (mercury) |
TXmetn |
toxic chemical pollution |
toxic metals - non-biomagnifying (copper) |
TXorgb |
toxic chemical pollution |
toxic organic chemicals - biomagnifying (PCBs) |
TXorgn |
toxic chemical pollution |
toxic organic chemicals - non-biomagnifying (PAHs) |
TXpest |
toxic chemical pollution |
toxic pesticides |
WDlake |
water withdrawals and diversions |
water withdrawals and diversions (Great Lakes) |
WDinld |
water withdrawals and diversions |
water withdrawals and diversions (inland and groundwater) |
ESA Publications | Ecological Archives | Permissions | Citation | Contacts