Ecological Archives M078-005-A4

Mark Hebblewhite, Evelyn Merrill, and Greg McDermid. 2008. A multi-scale test of the forage maturation hypothesis in a partially migratory ungulate population. Ecological Monographs 78:141–166.

Appendix D. Individual MODIS-interval quality–quantity regression equations.

Table D1. Quality–quantity trade-off linear regression models between herbaceous forage biomass (X1) and percentage digestibility (Y), and the constant (beta0), or average shrub percent digestibility for leaves and twigs for each 16-d MODIS interval, and an overall comparison between linear and exponential models for the herbaceous quality–quantity trade-off over the entire growing season.

 

beta1
(SE)

beta0
(SE)

N

F

df

P

R2

Mean shrub%
DMD-leaf

Mean shrub%
DMD-twig

M
R
M
R
Modis interval linear model                      

8 May

-0.45 (0.24)

54.7 (14.4)

13

3.5

7

0.1

0.25

70.8

68.6

66.8

64.0

24 May

-0.12 (0.13)

39.6 (8.9)

11

0.5

9

0.5

0.05

70.5

69.8

65.8

65.6

9 Jun

-0.09 (0.06)

39.0 (5.5)

27

2.3

25

0.12

0.09

71.1

70.7

66.3

66.9

25 Jun

-0.10 (0.03)

35.6 (3.4)

28

11.9

26

0.02

0.17

72.2

70.5

66.5

66.9

11 Jul

-0.13 (0.05)

39.0 (4.3)

41

7.6

25

0.01

0.25

71.8

69.7

66.9

65.4

27 Jul

-0.10 (0.05)

54.7 (4.7)

26

3.6

13

0.07

0.11

69.5

70.6

64.7

66.0

12 Aug

-0.10 (0.05)

37.5 (3.3)

42

3.9

28

0.05

0.15

68.6

69.0

63.6

63.6

28 Aug

-0.18 (0.05)

36.0 (3.8)

26

14.1

19

0.001

0.39

67.2

67.0

63.0

62.9

13 Sep

-0.33 (0.06)

39.8 (2.5)

9

37.0

7

0.005

0.7

67.1

66.7

63.1

63.8

29 Sep

--

--

1

--

--

--

--

--

--

--

--

Annual herbaceous linear and exponential model

Linear model

-0.12
(0.03)

38.1 (2.6)

224

15.7

33

0.001

0.18

69.9

69.2

65.2

65.0

Exponential model
Y=beta0 +beta1*beta2X1

beta0

beta1

beta2

N

F

df

P

R2

19.26
(5.50)

22.86 (4.564)

0.96 (0.008)

224

24.06

33

<0.001

0.22

Exponential model deltaAICc = 0.00

Linear model deltaAICc =6.51

   Notes: There was no significant linear or nonlinear relationship between shrub percentage DMD (dry-matter digestibility) either for leaf or twig and biomass, so the constant is reported. Note df is df2; df1 = 1 for all models. M = migrant elk, R = resident elk.



[Back to M078-005]