Ecological Archives E089-062-A2

Justine Karst, Laurie Marczak, Melanie D. Jones, and Roy Turkington. 2008. The mutualism–parasitism continuum in ectomycorrhizas: a quantitative assessment using meta-analysis. Ecology 89:1032–1042.

Appendix B. Identity of host plant and fungal species pairings with associated effect sizes [ln(R)] for seedling biomass, and full literature citations.

Authors

Host species

Fungal species

P addition
mg/kg

ln(R)
biomass

Bougher et al. 1990

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Descolea maculata

0

0.894

Bougher et al. 1990

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Descolea maculata

0

0.368

Bougher et al. 1990

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Laccaria laccata

0

0.575

Bougher et al. 1990

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Descolea maculata

2

1.170

Bougher et al. 1990

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Descolea maculata

2

1.170

Bougher et al. 1990

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Laccaria laccata

2

2.335

Bougher et al. 1990

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Descolea maculata

4

2.197

Bougher et al. 1990

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Descolea maculata

4

2.147

Bougher et al. 1990

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Laccaria laccata

4

3.050

Bougher et al. 1990

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Descolea maculata

8

1.603

Bougher et al. 1990

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Descolea maculata

8

1.518

Bougher et al. 1990

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Laccaria laccata

8

1.937

Bougher et al. 1990

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Descolea maculata

12

0.360

Bougher et al. 1990

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Descolea maculata

12

0.754

Bougher et al. 1990

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Laccaria laccata

12

0.873

Bougher et al. 1990

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Descolea maculata

16

0.182

Bougher et al. 1990

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Descolea maculata

16

0.416

Bougher et al. 1990

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Laccaria laccata

16

0.341

Bougher et al. 1990

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Descolea maculata

20

-0.259

Bougher et al. 1990

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Descolea maculata

20

-0.288

Bougher et al. 1990

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Laccaria laccata

20

-0.386

Bougher et al. 1990

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Descolea maculata

28

-0.062

Bougher et al. 1990

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Descolea maculata

28

-0.023

Bougher et al. 1990

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Laccaria laccata

28

-0.150

Bougher et al. 1990

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Descolea maculata

36

-0.168

Bougher et al. 1990

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Descolea maculata

36

-0.002

Bougher et al. 1990

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Laccaria laccata

36

0.013

Bougher et al. 1990

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Descolea maculata

48

-0.056

Bougher et al. 1990

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Descolea maculata

48

0.047

Bougher et al. 1990

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Laccaria laccata

48

-0.064

Browning and Whitney 1992

Picea mariana

Laccaria bicolor

1.5

0.275

Browning and Whitney 1992

Picea mariana

Laccaria bicolor

1.5

0.389

Browning and Whitney 1992

Pinus banksiana

Laccaria bicolor

1.5

0.512

Browning and Whitney 1992

Pinus banksiana

Laccaria bicolor

1.5

0.144

Browning and Whitney 1992

Picea mariana

Laccaria bicolor

7.2

-0.089

Browning and Whitney 1992

Picea mariana

Laccaria bicolor

7.2

-0.131

Browning and Whitney 1992

Pinus banksiana

Laccaria bicolor

7.2

0.331

Browning and Whitney 1992

Pinus banksiana

Laccaria bicolor

7.2

0.134

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus globulus

Cortinarius globuliformis

4

0.560

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus globulus

Paxillus muelleri

4

0.560

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus globulus

Hysterangium inflatum

4

0.118

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus globulus

Hysterangium inflatum

4

0.629

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus globulus

Thaxterogaster sp

4

0.694

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus globulus

Amanita xanthocephala

4

0.755

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus globulus

Hymenogaster zeylanicus

4

0.694

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus globulus

Hymenogaster viscidus

4

1.057

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus globulus

Hymenogaster zeylanicus

4

1.355

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus globulus

Setchelliogaster sp

4

1.099

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus globulus

Descolea maculata

4

1.771

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus globulus

Hydnangium carneum

4

1.682

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus globulus

Laccaria laccata

4

1.505

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus globulus

Laccaria laccata

4

1.853

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus globulus

Sclerodema verrucosum

4

1.771

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus globulus

Pisolithis tinctorius

4

2.421

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Cortinarius globuliformis

4

0.516

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Paxillus muelleri

4

0.921

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Hysterangium inflatum

4

0.307

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Hysterangium inflatum

4

0.429

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Thaxterogaster sp

4

0.997

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Amanita xanthocephala

4

0.544

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Hymenogaster zeylanicus

4

1.119

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Hymenogaster viscidus

4

0.806

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Hymenogaster zeylanicus

4

1.444

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Setchelliogaster sp

4

1.365

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Descolea maculata

4

1.805

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Hydnangium carneum

4

1.371

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Laccaria laccata

4

1.959

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Laccaria laccata

4

2.208

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Sclerodema verrucosum

4

1.914

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Pisolithis tinctorius

4

2.714

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus globulus

Cortinarius globuliformis

12

0.055

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus globulus

Paxillus muelleri

12

0.042

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus globulus

Hysterangium inflatum

12

0.002

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus globulus

Hysterangium inflatum

12

0.017

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus globulus

Thaxterogaster sp

12

0.045

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus globulus

Amanita xanthocephala

12

0.005

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus globulus

Hymenogaster zeylanicus

12

-0.008

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus globulus

Hymenogaster viscidus

12

0.034

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus globulus

Hymenogaster zeylanicus

12

-0.007

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus globulus

Setchelliogaster sp

12

-0.034

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus globulus

Descolea maculata

12

0.023

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus globulus

Hydnangium carneum

12

0.089

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus globulus

Laccaria laccata

12

-0.061

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus globulus

Laccaria laccata

12

0.065

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus globulus

Sclerodema verrucosum

12

0.012

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus globulus

Pisolithis tinctorius

12

0.040

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Cortinarius globuliformis

12

-0.317

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Paxillus muelleri

12

-0.380

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Hysterangium inflatum

12

-0.379

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Hysterangium inflatum

12

-0.178

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Thaxterogaster sp

12

-0.124

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Amanita xanthocephala

12

-0.106

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Hymenogaster zeylanicus

12

-0.541

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Hymenogaster viscidus

12

-0.156

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Hymenogaster zeylanicus

12

-0.007

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Setchelliogaster sp

12

-0.119

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Descolea maculata

12

-0.101

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Hydnangium carneum

12

0.097

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Laccaria laccata

12

-0.205

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Laccaria laccata

12

-0.065

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Sclerodema verrucosum

12

-0.081

Burgess et al. 1993

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Pisolithis tinctorius

12

-0.001

Chen et al. 2000

Eucalyptus globulus

Laccaria lateritia

5

0.368

Chen et al. 2000

Eucalyptus urophylla

Laccaria lateritia

5

2.048

Conjeaud et al. 1996

Pinus pinaster

Hebeloma cylindrosporum

0

 

Grandcourt et al. 2004

Dicorynia guianensis

unknown

0

0.342

Grandcourt et al. 2004

Eperua falcata

unknown

0

-0.209

Grandcourt et al. 2004

Dicorynia guianensis

unknown

8

1.228

Grandcourt et al. 2004

Eperua falcata

unknown

8

0.312

Grandcourt et al. 2004

Dicorynia guianensis

unknown

40

1.226

Grandcourt et al. 2004

Eperua falcata

unknown

40

0.344

Khasa et al. 2001

Pinus contorta

Hebeloma longicaudum

18

0.902

Khasa et al. 2001

Pinus contorta

Laccaria bicolor

18

0.853

Khasa et al. 2001

Pinus contorta

Paxillus involutus

18

0.936

Khasa et al. 2001

Pinus contorta

Pisolithis tinctorius

18

0.964

Khasa et al. 2001

Pinus contorta

Rhizopogon vinicolor

18

-0.015

Khasa et al. 2001

Pinus contorta

Suillis tomentosus

18

0.014

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea glauca

Hebeloma longicaudum

18

0.764

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea glauca

Laccaria bicolor

18

0.852

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea glauca

Paxillus involutus

18

1.246

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea glauca

Pisolithis tinctorius

18

1.222

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea glauca

Rhizopogon vinicolor

18

0.109

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea glauca

Suillis tomentosus

18

0.016

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea mariana

Hebeloma longicaudum

18

0.976

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea mariana

Laccaria bicolor

18

1.152

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea mariana

Paxillus involutus

18

1.677

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea mariana

Pisolithis tinctorius

18

1.366

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea mariana

Rhizopogon vinicolor

18

0.298

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea mariana

Suillis tomentosus

18

0.328

Khasa et al. 2001

Pinus sylvestris

Hebeloma longicaudum

18

0.066

Khasa et al. 2001

Pinus sylvestris

Laccaria bicolor

18

-0.040

Khasa et al. 2001

Pinus sylvestris

Paxillus involutus

18

0.176

Khasa et al. 2001

Pinus sylvestris

Pisolithis tinctorius

18

0.152

Khasa et al. 2001

Pinus sylvestris

Rhizopogon vinicolor

18

-0.034

Khasa et al. 2001

Pinus sylvestris

Suillis tomentosus

18

1.615

Khasa et al. 2001

Larix sibirica

Hebeloma longicaudum

18

0.074

Khasa et al. 2001

Larix sibirica

Laccaria bicolor

18

0.148

Khasa et al. 2001

Larix sibirica

Paxillus involutus

18

0.099

Khasa et al. 2001

Larix sibirica

Pisolithis tinctorius

18

0.084

Khasa et al. 2001

Larix sibirica

Rhizopogon vinicolor

18

0.027

Khasa et al. 2001

Larix sibirica

Suillis tomentosus

18

0.043

Khasa et al. 2001

Pinus contorta

Hebeloma longicaudum

37

0.781

Khasa et al. 2001

Pinus contorta

Laccaria bicolor

37

0.755

Khasa et al. 2001

Pinus contorta

Paxillus involutus

37

0.908

Khasa et al. 2001

Pinus contorta

Pisolithis tinctorius

37

0.862

Khasa et al. 2001

Pinus contorta

Rhizopogon vinicolor

37

0.016

Khasa et al. 2001

Pinus contorta

Suillis tomentosus

37

0.128

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea glauca

Hebeloma longicaudum

37

0.982

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea glauca

Laccaria bicolor

37

1.061

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea glauca

Paxillus involutus

37

1.281

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea glauca

Pisolithis tinctorius

37

1.135

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea glauca

Rhizopogon vinicolor

37

0.140

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea glauca

Suillis tomentosus

37

0.131

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea mariana

Hebeloma longicaudum

37

0.688

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea mariana

Laccaria bicolor

37

1.025

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea mariana

Paxillus involutus

37

1.217

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea mariana

Pisolithis tinctorius

37

1.134

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea mariana

Rhizopogon vinicolor

37

0.057

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea mariana

Suillis tomentosus

37

0.075

Khasa et al. 2001

Pinus sylvestris

Hebeloma longicaudum

37

-0.010

Khasa et al. 2001

Pinus sylvestris

Laccaria bicolor

37

0.044

Khasa et al. 2001

Pinus sylvestris

Paxillus involutus

37

0.334

Khasa et al. 2001

Pinus sylvestris

Pisolithis tinctorius

37

0.334

Khasa et al. 2001

Pinus sylvestris

Rhizopogon vinicolor

37

0.039

Khasa et al. 2001

Pinus sylvestris

Suillis tomentosus

37

0.034

Khasa et al. 2001

Larix sibirica

Hebeloma longicaudum

37

-0.585

Khasa et al. 2001

Larix sibirica

Laccaria bicolor

37

-0.522

Khasa et al. 2001

Larix sibirica

Paxillus involutus

37

-0.531

Khasa et al. 2001

Larix sibirica

Pisolithis tinctorius

37

-0.531

Khasa et al. 2001

Larix sibirica

Rhizopogon vinicolor

37

-0.648

Khasa et al. 2001

Larix sibirica

Suillis tomentosus

37

-0.618

Khasa et al. 2001

Pinus contorta

Hebeloma longicaudum

55

0.505

Khasa et al. 2001

Pinus contorta

Laccaria bicolor

55

0.485

Khasa et al. 2001

Pinus contorta

Paxillus involutus

55

0.729

Khasa et al. 2001

Pinus contorta

Pisolithis tinctorius

55

0.662

Khasa et al. 2001

Pinus contorta

Rhizopogon vinicolor

55

0.076

Khasa et al. 2001

Pinus contorta

Suillis tomentosus

55

0.086

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea glauca

Hebeloma longicaudum

55

0.670

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea glauca

Laccaria laccata

55

0.716

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea glauca

Paxillus involutus

55

0.849

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea glauca

Pisolithis tinctorius

55

0.911

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea glauca

Rhizopogon vinicolor

55

0.105

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea glauca

Suillis tomentosus

55

0.156

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea mariana

Hebeloma longicaudum

55

0.579

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea mariana

Laccaria bicolor

55

0.608

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea mariana

Paxillus involutus

55

0.795

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea mariana

Pisolithis tinctorius

55

0.793

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea mariana

Rhizopogon vinicolor

55

0.034

Khasa et al. 2001

Picea mariana