Ecological Archives E089-062-A1

Justine Karst, Laurie Marczak, Melanie D. Jones, and Roy Turkington. 2008. The mutualism–parasitism continuum in ectomycorrhizas: a quantitative assessment using meta-analysis. Ecology 89:1032–1042.

Appendix A. Identity of host plant and fungal species pairings and effect sizes [ln(R)] for seedling biomass, shoot height and shoot:root ratio for each study used in meta-analysis. Full citation for each study follows.

     

ln(R)

Authors

Host species

Fungal species

Biomass

Height

Shoot:root

     

n = 459

n = 329

n = 235

Baum et al. 2000

Populus trichocarpa

Laccaria bicolor

-0.518

-0.334

-0.522

Baum et al. 2000

Populus trichocarpa

Laccaria bicolor

0.856

0.529

1.627

Baum et al. 2000

Populus trichocarpa

Paxillus involutus

-0.319

-0.401

-0.895

Baum et al. 2000

Populus trichocarpa

Paxillus involutus

0.797

0.485

1.600

Baum et al. 2002

Populus trichocarpa

Laccaria laccata

 

0.305

 

Baum et al. 2002

Populus trichocarpa

Laccaria laccata

 

0.101

 

Baum et al. 2002

Populus trichocarpa

Laccaria laccata

 

0.005

 

Baumann et al. 2005

Pinus sylvestris

Paxillus involutus

0.251

 

-0.198

Baumann et al. 2005

Pinus sylvestris

Paxillus involutus

-0.111

 

0.358

Baumann et al. 2005

Pinus sylvestris

Paxillus involutus

0.064

 

-0.087

Baumann et al. 2005

Pinus sylvestris

Paxillus involutus

0.066

 

-0.399

Baumann et al. 2005

Pinus sylvestris

Paxillus involutus

0.292

 

0.048

Baumann et al. 2005

Pinus sylvestris

Paxillus involutus

     

Beyeler and Heyser 1997

Fagus sylvatica

Lactarius subdulcis

0.272

   

Bougher et al. 1990

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Descolea maculata

0.894

   

Bougher et al. 1990

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Descolea maculata

0.368

   

Bougher et al. 1990

Eucalyptus diversicolor

Laccaria laccata

0.575

   

Browning and Whitney 1991

Pinus banksiana

Pisolithus tinctorius

-0.031

 

0.236

Browning and Whitney 1991

Pinus banksiana

Cenococcum geophilum

0.000

 

0.086

Browning and Whitney 1991

Pinus banksiana

Laccaria proxima

-0.014

 

0.114

Browning and Whitney 1991

Pinus banksiana

Hebeloma cylindrosporum

-0.030

 

-0.150

Browning and Whitney 1991

Pinus banksiana

Tricholoma pessundatum

-0.065

 

0.233

Browning and Whitney 1991

Pinus banksiana

Thelephora terrestris

-0.046

 

0.231

Browning and Whitney 1991

Pinus banksiana

Suillus granulatus

-0.058

 

0.242

Browning and Whitney 1991

Pinus banksiana

Hebeloma cylindrosporum

0.126

 

-0.022

Browning and Whitney 1991

Pinus banksiana

Pisolithus tinctorius

0.163

 

-0.004

Browning and Whitney 1991

Pinus banksiana

Laccaria proxima

0.198

 

0.034

Browning and Whitney 1991

Pinus banksiana

Tricholoma pessundatum

0.138

 

0.143

Browning and Whitney 1991

Pinus banksiana

Cenococcum geophilum

0.129

 

-0.056

Browning and Whitney 1991

Picea mariana

Laccaria bicolor

-0.099

 

0.186

Browning and Whitney 1991

Picea mariana

Laccaria proxima

0.037

 

0.307

Browning and Whitney 1991

Picea mariana

Pisolithus tinctorius

-0.092

 

0.313

Browning and Whitney 1991

Picea mariana

Tricholoma pessundatum

-0.020

 

0.336

Browning and Whitney 1991

Picea mariana

Hebeloma cylindrosporum

-0.007

 

0.275

Browning and Whitney 1991

Picea mariana

Thelephora terrestris

0.030

 

0.374

Browning and Whitney 1991

Picea mariana

Cenococcum geophilum

0.020

 

0.306

Browning and Whitney 1991

Picea mariana

Suillus granulatus

0.020

 

0.234

Browning and Whitney 1991

Picea mariana

Laccaria bicolor

-0.104

 

0.153

Browning and Whitney 1991

Picea mariana

Hebeloma cylindrosporum

-0.005

 

0.329

Browning and Whitney 1991

Picea mariana

Pisolithus tinctorius

0.010

 

0.058

Browning and Whitney 1991

Picea mariana

Laccaria proxima

0.172

 

0.320

Browning and Whitney 1991

Picea mariana

Tricholoma pessundatum

-0.005

 

0.015

Burgess and Malajczuk 1989

Eucalyptus globulus

unknown

0.813

   

Burgess and Malajczuk 1989

Eucalyptus globulus

unknown

0.957

   

Burgess and Malajczuk 1989

Eucalyptus globulus

unknown

1.253

   

Burgess et al. 1994

Eucalyptus grandis

Pisolithus sp

0.511

0.303

 

Burgess et al. 1994

Eucalyptus grandis

Pisolithus sp

0.863

0.493

 

Burgess et al. 1994

Eucalyptus grandis

Pisolithus sp

1.111

0.614

 

Burgess et al. 1994

Eucalyptus grandis

Pisolithus sp

1.215

0.650

 

Burgess et al. 1994

Eucalyptus grandis

Pisolithus sp

1.804

1.249

 

Burgess et al. 1994

Eucalyptus grandis

Pisolithus sp

1.956

1.308

 

Burgess et al. 1994

Eucalyptus grandis

Pisolithus sp

2.408

1.434

 

Burgess et al. 1994

Eucalyptus grandis

Pisolithus sp

2.576

1.531

 

Burgess et al. 1994

Eucalyptus grandis

Pisolithus sp

2.650

1.590

 

Burgess et al. 1994

Eucalyptus grandis

Pisolithus sp

2.696

1.632

 

Burgess et al. 1994

Eucalyptus grandis

Pisolithus sp

2.802

1.646

 

Burgess et al. 1994

Eucalyptus grandis

Pisolithus sp

2.824

1.686

 

Burgess et al. 1994

Eucalyptus grandis

Pisolithus sp

3.086

1.762

 

Burgess et al. 1994

Eucalyptus grandis

Pisolithus sp

3.116

1.809

 

Burgess et al. 1994

Eucalyptus grandis

Pisolithus sp

3.173

1.843

 

Burgess et al. 1994

Eucalyptus grandis

Pisolithus sp

3.173

1.842

 

Burgess et al. 1994

Eucalyptus grandis

Pisolithus sp

3.189

1.886

 

Burgess et al. 1994

Eucalyptus grandis

Pisolithus sp

3.202

1.896

 

Burgess et al. 1994

Eucalyptus grandis

Pisolithus sp

3.305

1.928

 

Burgess et al. 1994

Eucalyptus grandis

Pisolithus sp

3.566

2.099

 

Chakravarty and Unestam 1987

Pinus sylvestris

Laccaria laccata

0.489

0.143

 

Chakravarty and Unestam 1987

Pinus sylvestris

Hebeloma crustulinforme

0.032

0.000

 

Chakravarty and Unestam 1987

Pinus sylvestris

Pisolithus tinctorius

0.614

0.208

 

Chakravarty and Unestam 1987

Pinus sylvestris

unknown

0.643

0.268

 

Chakravarty and Unestam 1987

Pinus sylvestris

Laccaria laccata

0.489

0.143

 

Chakravarty and Unestam 1987

Pinus sylvestris

Hebeloma crustulinforme

0.032

0.000

 

Chakravarty and Unestam 1987

Pinus sylvestris

Pisolithus tinctorius

0.614

0.208

 

Chakravarty and Unestam 1987

Pinus sylvestris

unknown

0.643

0.268

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus globulus

Scleroderma cepa

0.000

0.248

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus globulus

Scleroderma cepa

0.000

0.686

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus globulus

Scleroderma cepa

0.000

0.598

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus globulus

Scleroderma cepa

0.000

1.152

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus globulus

Scleroderma cepa

0.000

1.152

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus globulus

Scleroderma citrinum

0.000

0.092

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus globulus

Scleroderma citrinum

0.000

0.430

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus globulus

Scleroderma citrinum

0.000

0.213

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus globulus

Scleroderma citrinum

0.000

1.021

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus globulus

Scleroderma citrinum

0.000

1.510

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus urophylla

Scleroderma cepa

0.000

0.666

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus urophylla

Scleroderma cepa

0.000

0.759

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus urophylla

Scleroderma cepa

0.000

1.275

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus urophylla

Scleroderma cepa

0.000

1.214

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus urophylla

Scleroderma cepa

0.000

0.319

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus urophylla

Scleroderma citrinum

0.000

0.093

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus urophylla

Scleroderma citrinum

0.000

0.378

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus urophylla

Scleroderma citrinum

0.000

1.491

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus urophylla

Scleroderma citrinum

0.000

0.903

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus urophylla

Scleroderma citrinum

0.000

0.325

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus globulus

Scleroderma albidum

0.034

0.198

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus globulus

Scleroderma albidum

0.128

0.168

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus globulus

Scleroderma areolatum

0.128

0.104

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus globulus

Scleroderma areolatum

-0.116

0.059

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus globulus

Scleroderma areolatum

0.476

0.329

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus globulus

Scleroderma cepa

-0.065

0.021

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus globulus

Scleroderma cepa

0.049

0.238

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus globulus

Scleroderma cepa

0.311

0.104

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus globulus

Scleroderma citrinum

-0.112

0.104

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus globulus

Scleroderma citrinum

0.171

0.168

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus globulus

Scleroderma flavidum

0.153

0.147

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus globulus

Scleroderma flavidum

0.430

0.329

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus globulus

Scleroderma paradoxum

0.125

0.389

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus globulus

Scleroderma sp

0.220

0.247

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus globulus

Scleroderma verrucosum

0.155

0.168

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus urophylla

Scleroderma albidum

0.714

0.294

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus urophylla

Scleroderma albidum

0.042

0.216

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus urophylla

Scleroderma areolatum

0.300

0.152

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus urophylla

Scleroderma areolatum

0.005

0.184

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus urophylla

Scleroderma areolatum

0.123

0.205

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus urophylla

Scleroderma cepa

-0.079

0.108

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus urophylla

Scleroderma cepa

0.612

0.275

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus urophylla

Scleroderma cepa

-0.165

0.085

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus urophylla

Scleroderma citrinum

-0.214

-0.013

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus urophylla

Scleroderma citrinum

0.327

0.426

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus urophylla

Scleroderma flavidum

0.419

0.375

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus urophylla

Scleroderma flavidum

0.750

0.483

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus urophylla

Scleroderma paradoxum

0.451

0.393

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus urophylla

Scleroderma sp

0.559

0.536

 

Chen et al. 2006

Eucalyptus urophylla

Scleroderma verrucosum

0.507

0.331

 

Chen et al. 2006

Pinus elliottii

Scleroderma albidum

0.400

0.270

 

Chen et al. 2006

Pinus elliottii

Scleroderma albidum

0.253

0.277

 

Chen et al. 2006

Pinus elliottii

Scleroderma areolatum

-0.102

0.178

 

Chen et al. 2006

Pinus elliottii

Scleroderma areolatum

-0.150

0.109

 

Chen et al. 2006

Pinus elliottii

Scleroderma areolatum

0.302

0.034

 

Chen et al. 2006

Pinus elliottii

Scleroderma cepa

-0.221

0.079

 

Chen et al. 2006

Pinus elliottii

Scleroderma cepa

0.270

0.134

 

Chen et al. 2006

Pinus elliottii

Scleroderma cepa

-0.326

0.100

 

Chen et al. 2006

Pinus elliottii

Scleroderma citrinum

-0.312

-0.007

 

Chen et al. 2006

Pinus elliottii

Scleroderma citrinum

0.558

0.205

 

Chen et al. 2006

Pinus elliottii

Scleroderma flavidum

0.438

0.297

 

Chen et al. 2006

Pinus elliottii

Scleroderma flavidum

0.236

0.170

 

Chen et al. 2006

Pinus elliottii

Scleroderma paradoxum

0.224

0.146

 

Chen et al. 2006

Pinus elliottii

Scleroderma sp

0.224

0.170

 

Chen et al. 2006

Pinus elliottii

Scleroderma verrucosum

-0.262

0.021

 

Chen et al. 2006

Pinus radiata

Scleroderma albidum

0.959

0.342

 

Chen et al. 2006

Pinus radiata

Scleroderma albidum

1.260

0.302

 

Chen et al. 2006

Pinus radiata

Scleroderma areolatum

1.134

0.164

 

Chen et al. 2006

Pinus radiata

Scleroderma areolatum

0.895

0.146

 

Chen et al. 2006

Pinus radiata

Scleroderma areolatum

0.794

0.312

 

Chen et al. 2006

Pinus radiata

Scleroderma cepa

1.080

0.165

 

Chen et al. 2006

Pinus radiata

Scleroderma cepa

0.830

0.255

 

Chen et al. 2006

Pinus radiata

Scleroderma cepa

0.959

0.176

 

Chen et al. 2006

Pinus radiata

Scleroderma citrinum

0.391

0.070

 

Chen et al. 2006

Pinus radiata

Scleroderma citrinum

0.717

0.213

 

Chen et al. 2006

Pinus radiata

Scleroderma flavidum

0.935

0.435

 

Chen et al. 2006

Pinus radiata

Scleroderma flavidum

0.717

0.266

 

Chen et al. 2006

Pinus radiata

Scleroderma paradoxum

0.830

0.400

 

Chen et al. 2006

Pinus radiata

Scleroderma sp

0.747

0.422

 

Chen et al. 2006

Pinus radiata

Scleroderma verrucosum

0.623

0.198

 

Choi et al. 2005

Pinus densiflora

Pisolithus tinctorius

     

Choi et al. 2005

Pinus densiflora

Pisolithus tinctorius

     

Conjeaud et al. 1996

Pinus pinaster

Hebeloma cylindrosporum

     

Diedhiou et al. 2005

Afzelia africana

Scleroderma dictyosporum

0.303

 

-0.518

Diedhiou et al. 2005

Afzelia africana

Scleroderma verrucosum

0.175

 

-0.535

Diedhiou et al. 2005

Afzelia africana

Pisolithus sp

0.288

 

-0.417

Diedhiou et al. 2005

Afzelia africana

Thelephora sp

0.281

 

-0.461

Diedhiou et al. 2005

Afzelia bella

Scleroderma dictyosporum

0.571

 

-0.976

Diedhiou et al. 2005

Afzelia bella

Scleroderma verrucosum

0.595

 

-0.939

Diedhiou et al. 2005

Afzelia bella

Pisolithus sp

0.360

 

-1.182

Diedhiou et al. 2005

Afzelia bella

Thelephora sp

0.358

 

-0.973

Diedhiou et al. 2005

Anthonotha macrophylla

Scleroderma dictyosporum

0.081

 

0.181

Diedhiou et al. 2005

Anthonotha macrophylla

Scleroderma verrucosum

-0.010

 

0.214

Diedhiou et al. 2005

Anthonotha macrophylla

Pisolithus sp

0.199