Ecological Archives E089-021-A3

Ian Kaplan, Rayko Halitschke, André Kessler, Sandra Sardanelli, and Robert F. Denno. 2008. Constitutive and induced defenses to herbivory in above- and belowground plant tissues. Ecology 89:392–406.

Appendix C. Effect sizes and variances used in meta-analysis of root herbivory on aboveground secondary chemistry of Nicotiana tabacum by biosynthetic site.

Chemical Biosynthesis Foliar herbivory Effect size (d) Variance
nicotine roots none -1.7902 0.1934
alkaloid-1 roots none -1.6767 0.1866
alkaloid-3 roots none -1.9333 0.2025
alkaloid-4 roots none -0.1709 0.1386
chlorogenic acid leaves none 1.1951 0.1627
rutin leaves none 0.5248 0.1428
phenolic-2 leaves none 0.7754 0.1485
diterpene glycoside-1 leaves none 0.645 0.1453
diterpene glycoside-2 leaves none 1.0081 0.1556
diterpene glycoside-3 leaves none -0.1384 0.1384
diterpene glycoside-4 leaves none 0.3226 0.1399
diterpene glycoside-5 leaves none -0.2417 0.1391
diterpene glycoside-6 leaves none 0.2324 0.139
nicotine roots Manduca sexta -2.2483 0.242
alkaloid-1 roots Manduca sexta -1.5621 0.1935
alkaloid-3 roots Manduca sexta -1.8231 0.2099
alkaloid-4 roots Manduca sexta -0.9487 0.165
chlorogenic acid leaves Manduca sexta 1.3594 0.1826
rutin leaves Manduca sexta 0.2547 0.1496
phenolic-2 leaves Manduca sexta 1.0789 0.1699
diterpene glycoside-1 leaves Manduca sexta 0.5648 0.1543
diterpene glycoside-2 leaves Manduca sexta 0.6613 0.1564
diterpene glycoside-3 leaves Manduca sexta 0.5813 0.1546
diterpene glycoside-4 leaves Manduca sexta 0.6522 0.1562
diterpene glycoside-5 leaves Manduca sexta 0.7849 0.1598
diterpene glycoside-6 leaves Manduca sexta 0.523 0.1534
nicotine roots Trichoplusia ni -1.5532 0.2012
alkaloid-1 roots Trichoplusia ni -1.1377 0.1797
alkaloid-3 roots Trichoplusia ni -1.4772 0.1967
alkaloid-4 roots Trichoplusia ni -1.0004 0.174
chlorogenic acid leaves Trichoplusia ni -0.4307 0.1583
rutin leaves Trichoplusia ni -1.2188 0.1833
phenolic-2 leaves Trichoplusia ni 0.1874 0.1554
diterpene glycoside-1 leaves Trichoplusia ni 0.1186 0.155
diterpene glycoside-2 leaves Trichoplusia ni 0.3254 0.1568
diterpene glycoside-3 leaves Trichoplusia ni 0.3997 0.1578
diterpene glycoside-4 leaves Trichoplusia ni 0.5932 0.1615
diterpene glycoside-5 leaves Trichoplusia ni 0.1869 0.1554
diterpene glycoside-6 leaves Trichoplusia ni 0.4838 0.1593


[Back to E089-021]