Ecological Archives E089-021-A1

Ian Kaplan, Rayko Halitschke, André Kessler, Sandra Sardanelli, and Robert F. Denno. 2008. Constitutive and induced defenses to herbivory in above- and belowground plant tissues. Ecology 89:392–406.

Appendix A. Means and error per treatment and tissue type in Nicotiana tabacum damaged by foliar and root herbivores.

Root herbivory
Foliar herbivory
Tissue
N
Chemical
Mean
SE
yes control gall 10 nicotine 446.3673 66.11129
yes control gall 10 alkaloid-1 1623.087 267.3997
yes control gall 10 alkaloid-2 2512.766 231.9294
yes control gall 10 alkaloid-3 583.9699 55.54346
yes control gall 10 alkaloid-4 3513.721 137.977
yes control gall 10 chlorogenic acid 12.90341 3.374792
yes control gall 10 rutin 10.276 1.587739
yes control gall 10 phenolic-1 6063.91 484.7865
yes control gall 10 phenolic-2 49.88919 4.158237
yes Manduca sexta gall 13 nicotine 470.6542 44.11999
yes Manduca sexta gall 13 alkaloid-1 1667.669 143.9203
yes Manduca sexta gall 13 alkaloid-2 2582.545 131.6884
yes Manduca sexta gall 13 alkaloid-3 629.9759 33.44983
yes Manduca sexta gall 13 alkaloid-4 3976.171 266.6025
yes Manduca sexta gall 13 chlorogenic acid 20.2515 4.448375
yes Manduca sexta gall 13 rutin 10.17664 0.853032
yes Manduca sexta gall 13 phenolic-1 6550.519 318.4657
yes Manduca sexta gall 13 phenolic-2 57.4996 5.780093
yes Trichoplusia ni gall 12 nicotine 476.4955 52.55706
yes Trichoplusia ni gall 12 alkaloid-1 1609.388 150.1712
yes Trichoplusia ni gall 12 alkaloid-2 2407.914 118.0276
yes Trichoplusia ni gall 12 alkaloid-3 626.7341 46.64182
yes Trichoplusia ni gall 12 alkaloid-4 3932.737 284.9918
yes Trichoplusia ni gall 12 chlorogenic acid 27.80429 7.909376
yes Trichoplusia ni gall 12 rutin 9.571816 0.786572
yes Trichoplusia ni gall 12 phenolic-1 6061.455 254.5085
yes Trichoplusia ni gall 12 phenolic-2 63.10358 10.54575
no control leaf 15 nicotine 314.2659 18.37039
no control leaf 15 alkaloid-1 621.7837 25.48389
no control leaf 15 alkaloid-3 1051.648 30.42209
no control leaf 15 alkaloid-4 3578.87 90.92937
no control leaf 15 chlorogenic acid 38.80717 17.28433
no control leaf 15 rutin 11.00793 2.912815
no control leaf 15 phenolic-2 1.130147 0.487431
no control leaf 15 diterpene glycoside-1 12.74125 12.74125
no control leaf 15 diterpene glycoside-2 53.83391 14.89355
no control leaf 15 diterpene glycoside-3 44.77484 20.65595
no control leaf 15 diterpene glycoside-4 12.34261 7.594302
no control leaf 15 diterpene glycoside-5 200.755 33.47872
no control leaf 15 diterpene glycoside-6 103.9359 29.70258
no Manduca sexta leaf 13 nicotine 447.6504 34.33824
no Manduca sexta leaf 13 alkaloid-1 632.4663 28.85719
no Manduca sexta leaf 13 alkaloid-3 1073.405 36.23797
no Manduca sexta leaf 13 alkaloid-4 4260.003 207.7788
no Manduca sexta leaf 13 chlorogenic acid 21.27172 6.836681
no Manduca sexta leaf 13 rutin 5.958411 1.157598
no Manduca sexta leaf 13 phenolic-2 1.051092 0.47667
no Manduca sexta leaf 13 diterpene glycoside-1 259.7789 91.30073
no Manduca sexta leaf 13 diterpene glycoside-2 222.7294 53.97849
no Manduca sexta leaf 13 diterpene glycoside-3 71.94147 18.69234
no Manduca sexta leaf 13 diterpene glycoside-4 19.56674 11.10222
no Manduca sexta leaf 13 diterpene glycoside-5 171.5401 20.03922
no Manduca sexta leaf 13 diterpene glycoside-6 89.53908 19.32573
no Trichoplusia ni leaf 14 nicotine 580.0961 75.46167
no Trichoplusia ni leaf 14 alkaloid-1 686.7971 43.32558
no Trichoplusia ni leaf 14 alkaloid-3 1125.076 45.37523
no Trichoplusia ni leaf 14 alkaloid-4 4378.073 239.3222
no Trichoplusia ni leaf 14 chlorogenic acid 124.945 51.73313
no Trichoplusia ni leaf 14 rutin 15.52031 3.22911
no Trichoplusia ni leaf 14 phenolic-2 3.312316 1.38633
no Trichoplusia ni leaf 14 diterpene glycoside-1 4623.415 1444.58
no Trichoplusia ni leaf 14 diterpene glycoside-2 2892.622 872.6107
no Trichoplusia ni leaf 14 diterpene glycoside-3 1597.665 886.8781
no Trichoplusia ni leaf 14 diterpene glycoside-4 809.2713 425.6309
no Trichoplusia ni leaf 14 diterpene glycoside-5 536.011 90.26512
no Trichoplusia ni leaf 14 diterpene glycoside-6 175.1053 23.43117
yes control leaf 14 nicotine 192.121 16.21779
yes control leaf 14 alkaloid-1 447.3482 27.70539
yes control leaf 14 alkaloid-3 786.7593 39.53692
yes control leaf 14 alkaloid-4 3482.491 187.2318
yes control leaf 14 chlorogenic acid 176.9794 39.09861
yes control leaf 14 rutin 18.86359 4.64862
yes control leaf 14 phenolic-2 3.339747 0.929501
yes control leaf 14 diterpene glycoside-1 78.34858 35.53575
yes control leaf 14 diterpene glycoside-2 132.2299 24.32381
yes control leaf 14 diterpene glycoside-3 35.08961 13.92981
yes control leaf 14 diterpene glycoside-4 27.74168 15.89936
yes control leaf 14 diterpene glycoside-5 169.5783 32.23128
yes control leaf 14 diterpene glycoside-6 134.4447 37.39248
yes Manduca sexta leaf 14 nicotine 215.5984 19.1139
yes Manduca sexta leaf 14 alkaloid-1 472.1188 25.44154
yes Manduca sexta leaf 14 alkaloid-3 819.3653 37.18079
yes Manduca sexta leaf 14 alkaloid-4 3658.651 122.0243
yes Manduca sexta leaf 14 chlorogenic acid 82.21558 14.8169
yes Manduca sexta leaf 14 rutin 8.133775 2.87626
yes Manduca sexta leaf 14 phenolic-2 4.004165 0.879167
yes Manduca sexta leaf 14 diterpene glycoside-1 1199.796 592.1974
yes Manduca sexta leaf 14 diterpene glycoside-2 997.9205 418.3424
yes Manduca sexta leaf 14 diterpene glycoside-3 669.0198 368.7443
yes Manduca sexta leaf 14 diterpene glycoside-4 420.3756 220.6222
yes Manduca sexta leaf 14 diterpene glycoside-5 321.6525 66.18158
yes Manduca sexta leaf 14 diterpene glycoside-6 151.6413 38.74394
yes Trichoplusia ni leaf 12 nicotine 238.6575 19.70785
yes Trichoplusia ni leaf 12 alkaloid-1 528.9818 26.32376
yes Trichoplusia ni leaf 12 alkaloid-3 874.9581 45.2753
yes Trichoplusia ni leaf 12 alkaloid-4 3623.233 134.5818
yes Trichoplusia ni leaf 12 chlorogenic acid 59.66017 15.11796
yes Trichoplusia ni leaf 12 rutin 3.635501 1.354923
yes Trichoplusia ni leaf 12 phenolic-2 4.349883 1.60578
yes Trichoplusia ni leaf 12 diterpene glycoside-1 5295.917 1613.038
yes Trichoplusia ni leaf 12 diterpene glycoside-2 4152.119 1226.772
yes Trichoplusia ni leaf 12 diterpene glycoside-3 2968.847 960.3903
yes Trichoplusia ni leaf 12 diterpene glycoside-4 1984.863 648.0061
yes Trichoplusia ni leaf 12 diterpene glycoside-5 620.3408 153.2275
yes Trichoplusia ni leaf 12 diterpene glycoside-6 245.397 53.31841
no control root 15 nicotine 217.088 17.60369
no control root 15 alkaloid-1 690.8211 43.49662
no control root 15 alkaloid-2 1353.398 68.90651
no control root 15 alkaloid-3 279.5212 19.90666
no control root 15 alkaloid-4 1265.646 56.49961
no control root 15 chlorogenic acid 28.35899 2.819803
no control root 15 rutin 0.121953 0.061532
no control root 15 phenolic-1 941.4022 83.9689
no control root 15 phenolic-2 7.10108 0.771755
no Manduca sexta root 13 nicotine 212.8112 17.93813
no Manduca sexta root 13 alkaloid-1 613.7571 41.46386
no Manduca sexta root 13 alkaloid-2 1396.294 97.83926
no Manduca sexta root 13 alkaloid-3 259.208 22.57136
no Manduca sexta root 13 alkaloid-4 1305.178 116.3597
no Manduca sexta root 13 chlorogenic acid 28.07678 2.90152
no Manduca sexta root 13 rutin 0.099587 0.081916
no Manduca sexta root 13 phenolic-1 853.7602 61.71523
no Manduca sexta root 13 phenolic-2 8.785615 0.914115
no Trichoplusia ni root 14 nicotine 204.3845 21.91391
no Trichoplusia ni root 14 alkaloid-1 736.3584 76.08218
no Trichoplusia ni root 14 alkaloid-2 1386.736 102.6898
no Trichoplusia ni root 14 alkaloid-3 300.9121 25.39612
no Trichoplusia ni root 14 alkaloid-4 1470.162 130.8597
no Trichoplusia ni root 14 chlorogenic acid 31.68164 3.71902
no Trichoplusia ni root 14 rutin 0.132254 0.089852
no Trichoplusia ni root 14 phenolic-1 995.0347 131.2986
no Trichoplusia ni root 14 phenolic-2 10.59428 1.838645
yes control root 13 nicotine 119.9648 16.16961
yes control root 13 alkaloid-1 446.6201 43.60825
yes control root 13 alkaloid-2 974.0685 83.57494
yes control root 13 alkaloid-3 173.6047 17.93843
yes control root 13 alkaloid-4 1282.618 153.3918
yes control root 13 chlorogenic acid 30.27477 3.46436
yes control root 13 rutin 0.600836 0.241912
yes control root 13 phenolic-1 1352.837 139.4777
yes control root 13 phenolic-2 16.75112 2.230691
yes Manduca sexta root 12 nicotine 141.5731 14.49164
yes Manduca sexta root 12 alkaloid-1 465.4288 27.5977
yes Manduca sexta root 12 alkaloid-2 979.3794 64.40615
yes Manduca sexta root 12 alkaloid-3 198.0167 12.56453
yes Manduca sexta root 12 alkaloid-4 1301.068 87.27688
yes Manduca sexta root 12 chlorogenic acid 26.87983 4.238051
yes Manduca sexta root 12 rutin 0.485476 0.324446
yes Manduca sexta root 12 phenolic-1 1179.891 81.18132
yes Manduca sexta root 12 phenolic-2 14.41647 1.485427
yes Trichoplusia ni root 12 nicotine 121.6 12.11027
yes Trichoplusia ni root 12 alkaloid-1 464.4506 35.92971
yes Trichoplusia ni root 12 alkaloid-2 896.7362 72.59009
yes Trichoplusia ni root 12 alkaloid-3 178.8919 18.96263
yes Trichoplusia ni root 12 alkaloid-4 1153.705 94.27485
yes Trichoplusia ni root 12 chlorogenic acid 32.88584 3.637947
yes Trichoplusia ni root 12 rutin 0.211904 0.139527
yes Trichoplusia ni root 12 phenolic-1 1105.38 99.78957
yes Trichoplusia ni root 12 phenolic-2 12.27997 1.328521


[Back to E089-021]