Ecological Archives E088-063-A1

William F. Morris, Ruth A. Hufbauer, Anurag A. Agrawal, James D. Bever, Victoria A. Borowicz, Gregory S. Gilbert, John L. Maron, Charles E. Mitchell, Ingrid M. Parker, Alison G. Power, Mark E. Torchin, and Diego P. Vázquez. 2007. Direct and interactive effects of enemies and mutualists on plant performance: a meta-analysis. Ecology 88:1021–1029.

Appendix A. Articles and data used in the meta-analysis.

TABLE A1. Articles included in the meta-analysis, and numbers of data points contributed.

Article

 

Number of data points

 
 

Different agents
and independent controls

Different agents

Different controls

All data

Enemy–Enemy Interactions

       

Abdel-Momen and Starr 1998

1

1

2

2

Anderson and Paige 2003

1

1

1

1

Bertrand et al. 2000

1

2

1

2

Colvin et al. 2000

1

1

1

1

Dewalt et al. 2004

1

1

1

1

Eubanks et al. 2005

1

1

2

2

Greipsson and El-Mayas 2002

1

1

1

2

Hougen-Eitzman and Rausher 1994

1

1

2

2

Houle and Simard 1996

1

1

1

1

Hufbauer and Root 2002

1

1

1

1

Hunt-Joshi et al. 2004

1

1

1

1

Juenger and Bergelson 1998

3

3

3

3

Karban and Strauss 1993

1

1

1

1

Keary and Hatcher 2004

1

1

1

1

Longland et al. 2001

1

1

1

1

Maron 1998

1

1

1

1

Moron-Rios et al. 1997

1

1

1

1

Owor et al. 2004

1

1

2

2

Pethybridge et al. 2002

1

3

1

3

Poveda et al. 2003

1

1

1

1

Salt et al. 1996

1

1

1

1

Strauss 1991

1

1

1

1

Walker et al. 2000

1

1

1

1

Warner and Cushman 2002

1

1

1

1

Wise and Sacchi 1996

1

1

2

2

EE Total

27

30

32

36

         

Enemy–Mutualist

       

Abdalla and Abdel-Fattah 2000

1

3

1

3

Adler 2003

1

1

2

2

Arizmendi et al. 1996

2

2

2

2

Bååth and Hayman 1983

1

1

4

6

Bagyaraj et al. 1979

1

2

2

2

Diederichs 1987

1

5

1

5

Ganade and Brown 1997

2

2

2

2

Gange 2001

1

3

1

3

Gange et al. 1994

1

1

1

2

Garcia and Ehrlén 2002

1

1

1

1

Garcia-Garrido and Ocampo 1989

1

1

2

2

Gernns at al. 2001

2

1

2

2

Gomez 2005

1

1

1

1

Greipsson and El-Mayas 2002

1

2

1

4

Herrera 2000

1

1

1

1

Herrera et al. 2002

1

1

1

1

Juenger and Bergelson 1997, 2000

1

1

2

2

Kaye et al. 1984

1

1

1

3

Knight 2004

1

1

1

1

Krishna and Bagyaraj 1983

1

1

1

2

Little and Maun 1996

1

1

2

2

MacGuidwin et al. 1985

1

1

1

1

Mothershead and Marquis 2000

1

1

1

1

Newsham et al. 1995

1

1

1

1

Price et al. 1995

1

1

1

1

Ryder et al. 19992

6

6

8

28

Sen 2001

1

3

1

3

Sharaf and Price 2004

1

1

2

2

Siddiqui and Mahmood 1995

1

2

4

8

Smith et al. 1986

1

1

1

1

Strauss and Murch 2004

1

1

1

1

Strobel et al. 1982

1

2

3

6

Thomas et al. 1994

1

3

1

3

Trotta et al. 1996

1

1

2

2

Vaast et al. 1998

1

2

1

4

Wamberg et al. 2003

1

1

1

1

Winkler et al. 1994

1

1

2

2

EM Total

45

61

63

114

         

Mutualist–Mutualist

       

Altshuler 1999

1

1

1

1

Domenech et al. 2004

1

2

1

2

Oliveira et al. 2005

1

1

1

1

Shafer et al. 1996

1

2

1

2

Weber et al. 2005

1

1

1

1

Yamanaka et al. 2005

2

2

1

3

MM Total

7

9

6

10

         

Grand Total

791

100

1011

160

1 The Greipsson and El Mayas (2002) study contributed to both the EE and EM categories, but the experiment shared a control, and so the total data available across all categories is one fewer than the sum of the three separate categories.

2 Ryder et al. 1999 evaluated the effects of soil-borne pathogens with and without multiple strains of several species of mutualistic bacteria. When subsampling, we randomly included a single strain of each of the bacterial species in each iteration.

LITERATURE CITED

Abdalla, M. E., and G. M. Abdel-Fattah. 2000. Influence of the endomycorrhizal fungus Glomus mosseae on the development of peanut pod rot disease in Egypt . Mycorrhiza 10:29–35.

Abdel-Momen, S. M., and J. L. Starr. 1998. Meloidogyne javanica-Rhizoctonia solani disease complex of peanut. Fundamental and Applied Nematology 21:611–616.

Adler, L. S. 2003. Host species affects herbivory, pollination, and reproduction in experiments with parasitic Castilleja. Ecology 84:2083–2091.

Altshuler, D. L. 1999. Novel interactions of non-pollinating ants with pollinators and fruit consumers in a tropical forest. Oecologia 119:600–606.

Anderson, L. L., and K. N. Paige. 2003. Multiple herbivores and coevolutionary interactions in an Ipomopsis hybrid swarm. Evolutionary Ecology 17:139–156.

Arizmendi, M. C., C. A. Dominguez, and R. Dirzo. 1996. The role of an avian nectar robber and of Hummingbird pollinators in the reproduction of two plant species. Functional Ecology 10:119–127.

Bååth, E., and D. S. Hayman. 1983. Plant growth responses to vesicular-arbuscular mycorrhiza .14. Interactions with Verticillium wilt on tomato plants. New Phytologist 95:419–426.

Bagyaraj, D. J., A. Manjunath, and D. D. R. Reddy. 1979. Interaction of vesicular arbuscular mycorrhiza with root-knot nematodes in tomato. Plant and Soil 51:397–403.

Bertrand, B., C. Nunez, and J. L. Sarah. 2000. Disease complex in coffee involving Meloidogyne arabicida and Fusarium oxysporum. Plant Pathology 49:383–388.

Colvin, J., C. A. Omongo, M. N. Maruthi, G. W. Otim-Nape, and J. M. Thresh. 2004. Dual begomovirus infections and high Bemisia tabaci populations: two factors driving the spread of a cassava mosaic disease pandemic. Plant Pathology 53:577–584.

DeWalt, S. J., J. S. Denslow, and K. Ickes. 2004. Natural-enemy release facilitates habitat expansion of the invasive tropical shrub Clidemia hirta. Ecology 85:471–483.

Diederichs, C. 1987. Interaction between 5 endomycorrhizal fungi and the root-knot nematode Meloidogyne javanica on chickpea under tropical conditions. Tropical Agriculture 64:353–355.

Domenech, J., B. Ramos-Solano, A. Probanza, J. A. Lucas-Garcia, J. J. Colon, and F. J. Gutierrez-Manero. 2004. Bacillus spp. and Pisolithus tinctorius effects on Quercus ilex ssp ballota: a study on tree growth, rhizosphere community structure and mycorrhizal infection. Forest Ecology And Management 194:293–303.

Eubanks, M. D., D. E. Carr, and J. F. Murphy. 2005. Variation in the response of Mimulus guttatus (Scrophulariaceae) to herbivore and virus attack. Evolutionary Ecology 19:15–27.

Ganade, G., and V. K. Brown. 1997. Effects of below-ground insects, mycorrhizal fungi and soil fertility on the establishment of Vicia in grassland communities. Oecologia 109:374–381.

Gange, A. C. 2001. Species-specific responses of a root- and shoot-feeding insect to arbuscular mycorrhizal colonization of its host plant. New Phytologist 150:611–618.

Gange, A. C., V. K. Brown, and G. S. Sinclair. 1994. Reduction of black vine weevil larval growth by vesicular arbuscular mycorrhizal infection. Entomologia Experimentalis Et Applicata 70:115–119.

Garcia, M. B., and J. Ehrlén. 2002. Reproductive effort and herbivory timing in a perennial herb: Fitness components at the individual and population levels. American Journal of Botany 89:1295–1302.

Garcia-Garrido, J., and J. Ocampo. 1989. Effect of VA mycorrhizal infection of tomato on damage caused by Pseudomonas syringae. Soil Biology and Biochemistry 21:165–167.

Gernns, H., H. von Alten, and H. M. Poehling. 2001. Arbuscular mycorrhiza increased the activity of a biotrophic leaf pathogen - is a compensation possible? Mycorrhiza 11:237–243.

Gomez, J. M. 2005. Non-additive effects of herbivores and pollinators on Erysimum mediohispanicum (Cruciferae) fitness. Oecologia 143:412–418.

Greipsson, S., and H. El-Mayas. 2002. Synergistic effect of soil pathogenic fungi and nematodes reducing bioprotection of arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi on the grass Leymus arenarius. Biocontrol 47:715–727.

Herrera, C. M. 2000. Measuring the effects of pollinators and herbivores: Evidence for non-additivity in a perennial herb. Ecology 81:2170–2176.

Herrera, C. M., M. Medrano, P. J. Rey, A. M. Sanchez-Lafuente, M. B. Garcia, J. Guitian, and A. J. Manzaneda. 2002. Interaction of pollinators and herbivores on plant fitness suggests a pathway for correlated evolution of mutualism- and antagonism-related traits. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 99:16823–16828.

Hougen-Eitzman, D., and M. D. Rausher. 1994. Interactions between herbivorous insects and plant-insect coevolution. American Naturalist 143:677–697.

Houle, G., and G. Simard. 1996. Additive effects of genotype, nutrient availability and type of tissue damage on the compensatory response of Salix planifolia ssp planifolia to simulated herbivory. Oecologia 107:373–378.

Hufbauer, R. A., and R. B. Root. 2002. Interactive effects of different types of herbivore damage: Trirhabda beetle larvae and Philaenus spittlebugs on goldenrod (Solidago altissima). American Midland Naturalist 147:204–213.

Hunt-Joshi, T. R., B. Blossey, and R. B. Root. 2004. Root and leaf herbivory on Lythrum salicaria: Implications for plant performance and communities. Ecological Applications 14:1574–1589.

Juenger, T., and J. Bergelson. 1997. Pollen and resource limitation of compensation to herbivory in scarlet gilia, Ipomopsis aggregata. Ecology 78:1684–1695.

Juenger, T., and J. Bergelson. 1998. Pairwise versus diffuse natural selection and the multiple herbivores of scarlet gilia, Ipomopsis aggregata. Evolution 52:1583–1592.

Juenger, T., and J. Bergelson. 2000. Does early season browsing influence the effect of self-pollination in scarlet gilia? Ecology 81:41–48.

Karban, R., and S. Y. Strauss. 1993. Effects of herbivores on growth and reproduction of their perennial host, Erigeron glaucus. Ecology 74:39–46.

Kaye, J. W., F. L. Pfleger, and E. L. Stewart. 1984. Interaction of Glomus fasciculatum and Pythium utimum on greenhouse grown poinsettia. Canadian Journal of Botany-Revue Canadienne De Botanique 62:1575–1579.

Keary, I. P., and P. E. Hatcher. 2004. Combining competition from Lolium perenne and an insect-fungus combination to control Rumex obtusifolius seedlings. Weed Research 44:33–41.

Knight, T. M. 2004. The effect of herbivory and pollen limitation on a declining population of Trillium grandiflorum. Ecological Applications 14:915–928.

Krishna, K. R., and D. J. Bagyaraj. 1983. Interaction between Glomus fasciculatum and Sclerotium rolfsii in peanut. Canadian Journal of Botany-Revue Canadienne De Botanique 61:2349–2351.

Little, L. R., and M. A. Maun. 1996. The 'Ammophila problem' revisited: A role for mycorrhizal fungi. Journal of Ecology 84:1–7.

Longland, W. S., S. H. Jenkins, S. B. Vander Wall, J. A. Veech, and S. Pyare. 2001. Seedling recruitment in Oryzopsis hymenoides: Are desert granivores mutualists or predators? Ecology 82:3131–3148.

MacGuidwin, A. E., G. W. Bird, and G. R. Safir. 1985. Influence of Glomus fasciculatum on Meloidogyne hapla infecting Allium cepa. Journal of Nematology 17:389–395.

Maron, J. L. 1998. Insect herbivory above- and belowground: Individual and joint effects on plant fitness. Ecology 79:1281–1293.

Moron-Rios, A., R. Dirzo, and V. J. Jaramillo. 1997. Defoliation and below-ground herbivory in the grass Muhlenbergia quadridentata: Effects an plant performance and on the root-feeder Phyllophaga sp. (Coleoptera, Melolonthidae). Oecologia 110:237–242.

Mothershead, K., and R. J. Marquis. 2000. Fitness impacts of herbivory through indirect effects on plant-pollinator interactions in Oenothera macrocarpa. Ecology 81:30–40.

Newsham, K. K., A. H. Fitter, and A. R. Watkinson. 1995. Arbuscular mycorrhiza protect an annual grass from root pathogenic fungi in the field. Journal of Ecology 83:991–1000.

Oliveira, R. S., P. M. L. Castro, J. C. Dodd, and M. Vosatka. 2005. Synergistic effect of Glomus intraradices and Frankia spp. on the growth and stress recovery of Alnus glutinosa in an alkaline anthropogenic sediment. Chemosphere 60:1462–1470.

Owor, B., J. P. Legg, G. Okao-Okuja, R. Obonyo, and M. W. Ogenga-Latigo. 2004. The effect of cassava mosaic geminiviruses on symptom severity, growth and root yield of a cassava mosaic virus disease-susceptible cultivar in Uganda . Annals of Applied Biology 145:331–337.

Pethybridge, S. J., M. E. Nelson, K. C. Eastwell, R. E. Klein, S. T. Kenny, and C. R. Wilson. 2002. Incidence and spatial distribution of viruses in hop gardens of Washington State. Plant Disease 86:661–665.

Poveda, K., I. Steffan-Dewenter, S. Scheu, and T. Tscharntke. 2003. Effects of below- and above-ground herbivores on plant growth, flower visitation and seed set. Oecologia 135:601–605.

Price, N. S., R. W. Roncadori, and R. S. Hussey. 1995. The growth of nematode tolerant and intolerant soybeans as affected by phosphorus, Glomus intraradices and light. Plant Pathology 44:597–603.

Ryder, M. H., Z. N. Yan, T. E. Terrace, A. D. Rovira, W. H. Tang, and R. L. Correll. 1999. Use of strains of Bacillus isolated in China to suppress take-all and rhizoctonia root rot, and promote seedling growth of glasshouse-grown wheat in Australian soils. Soil Biology and Biochemistry 31:19–29.

Salt, D. T., P. Fenwick, and J. B. Whittaker. 1996. Interspecific herbivore interactions in a high CO2 environment: Root and shoot aphids feeding on Cardamine. Oikos 77:326–330.

Sen, R. 2001. Multitrophic interactions between a Rhizoctonia sp and mycorrhizal fungi affect Scots pine seedling performance in nursery soil. New Phytologist 152:543–553.

Shafer, S. R., M. M. Schoeneberger, S. J. Horton, C. B. Davey, and J. E. Miller. 1996. Effects of rhizobium, arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi and anion content of simulated rain on subterranean clover. Environmental Pollution 92:55–66.

Sharaf, K. E., and M. V. Price. 2004. Does pollination limit tolerance to browsing in Ipomopsis aggregata? Oecologia 138:396–404.

Siddiqui, Z. A., and I. Mahmood. 1995. Some observations on the management of the wilt disease complex of pigeonpea by treatment with a vesicular arbuscular fungus and biocontrol agents for nematodes. Bioresource Technology 54:227–230.

Smith, G. S., R. W. Roncadori, and R. S. Hussey. 1986. Interaction of endomycorrhizal fungi, superphosphate, and Meloidogyne incognita on cotton in microplot and field studies. Journal of Nematology 18:208–216.

Strauss, S. Y. 1991. Direct, indirect, and cumulative effects of three native herbivores on a shared host plant. Ecology 72:543–558.

Strauss, S. Y., and P. Murch. 2004. Towards an understanding of the mechanisms of tolerance: compensating for herbivore damage by enhancing a mutualism. Ecological Entomology 29:234–239.

Strobel, N. E., R. S. Hussey, and R. W. Roncadori. 1982. Interactions of vesicular arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi, Meloidogyne incognita, and soil fertility on peach. Phytopathology 72:690–694.

Thomas, L., B. C. Mallesha, and D. J. Bagyaraj. 1994. Biological control of damping-off of cardamom by the VA mycorrhizal mungus, Glomus fasciculatum. Microbiological Research 149:413–417.

Trotta, A., G. C. Varese, E. Gnavi, A. Fusconi, S. Sampo, and G. Berta. 1996. Interactions between the soilborne root pathogen Phytophthora nicotianae var parasitica and the arbuscular mycorrhizal fungus Glomus mosseae in tomato plants. Plant and Soil 185:199–209.

Vaast, P., E. P. Caswell-Chen, and R. J. Zasoski. 1998. Influences of a root-lesion nematode, Pratylenchus coffeae, and two arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi, Acaulospora mellea and Glomus clarum on coffee (Coffea arabica L.). Biology and Fertility of Soils 26:130–135.

Walker, N. R., T. L. Kirkpatrick, and C. S. Rothrock. 2000. Influence of Meloidogyne incognita and Thielaviopsis basicola populations on early-season disease development and cotton growth. Plant Disease 84:449–453.

Wamberg, C., S. Christensen, and I. Jakobsen. 2003. Interaction between foliar-feeding insects, mycorrhizal fungi, and rhizosphere protozoa on pea plants. Pedobiologia 47:281–287.

Warner, P. J., and J. H. Cushman. 2002. Influence of herbivores on a perennial plant: variation with life history stage and herbivore species. Oecologia 132:77–85.

Weber, J., M. Ducousso, F. Y. Tham, S. Nourissier-Mountou, A. Galiana, Y. Prin, and S. K. Lee. 2005. Co-inoculation of Acacia mangium with Glomus intraradices and Bradyrhizobium sp in aeroponic culture. Biology and Fertility of Soils 41:233–239.

Winkler, H. E., B. A. D. Hetrick, and T. C. Todd. 1994. Interactions of Heterodera gycines, Macrophomina phaseolina, and mycorrhizal fungi on soybean in Kansas. Journal of Nematology 26:675–682.

Wise, M. J., and C. F. Sacchi. 1996. Impact of two specialist insect herbivores on reproduction of horse nettle, Solanum carolinense. Oecologia 108:328–337.

Yamanaka, T., A. Akama, C. Y. Li, and H. Okabe. 2005. Growth, nitrogen fixation and mineral acquisition of Alnus sieboldiana after inoculation of Frankia together with Gigaspora margarita and Pseudomonas putida. Journal of Forest Research 10:21–26.



[Back to E088-063]